top 10

kremlin
03-22-2005, 07:39 AM
Rank the top 10 players in the WHL this season, now that the regular season is over!

bruins_19
03-22-2005, 02:13 PM
1. Dion Phaneuf
2. Eric Fehr
3. Nigel Dawes
4. Gilbert Brule
5. Stefan Meyer
6. Mike Green
7. Jeff Glass
8. Ryan Stone
9. Cam Barker
10. Brent Seabrook


Just Didnt Make The Cut: Colton Yellow Horn, Clarke Macaurthur, Matt Keetley, Jonathon Filewich, Ryan Getzlaf, Andrew Ladd, Colin Fraser, Roman Wick, Braydon Coburn, Shea Webber.

monster_bertuzzi
03-22-2005, 02:51 PM
1. Dion Phaneuf
2. Eric Fehr
3. Nigel Dawes
4. Gilbert Brule
5. Stefan Meyer
6. Mike Green
7. Jeff Glass
8. Ryan Stone
9. Cam Barker
10. Brent Seabrook


Just Didnt Make The Cut: Colton Yellow Horn, Clarke Macaurthur, Matt Keetley, Jonathon Filewich, Ryan Getzlaf, Andrew Ladd, Colin Fraser, Roman Wick, Braydon Coburn, Shea Webber.

I would hope not..

1)Eric Fehr
2)Dion Phaneuf
3)Gilbert Brule
4)Nigel Dawes
5)Ryan Stone
6)Jeff Glass
7)Mike Green
8)Derek Yeomans
9)Brent Seabrook
10)Jonathan Filewich

Almost: Yellow Horn, Weber, Meszaros, Meyer,

bruins_19
03-22-2005, 04:55 PM
Mezaros over Barker? Filewich over Meyer?
Not trying to be a tiger homer here but I have seen the tigers play probably more than anyother WHL team and right behind them would be Lethbridge. I know that Filewich had more points but I dont see him being better than Meyer this year. Ive seen Filewich more this year than Meyer and I agree Filewich had a breakout season but he isnt as much of a need for the team than Meyer is?

and just wondering why u would have mezaros on the almost list and not barker. Barker had more points in less games and I agree Mezaros has a slight upside that barker. Hopefully you can change my mind between those 2 picks. Maybe watching one team more has turned me into a homer for the hat but Id really like to hear what u think.

Big Cat Davo
03-22-2005, 05:28 PM
Kris Russel was a better D man this season than Barker. How can Barker rank in the leagues top ten when he was not even the Tigers best?

Russel may be small, but he out pointed Barker, out hustles him every night, and is better in his own end.

Dave

monster_bertuzzi
03-22-2005, 06:10 PM
Mezaros over Barker? Filewich over Meyer?
Not trying to be a tiger homer here but I have seen the tigers play probably more than anyother WHL team and right behind them would be Lethbridge. I know that Filewich had more points but I dont see him being better than Meyer this year. Ive seen Filewich more this year than Meyer and I agree Filewich had a breakout season but he isnt as much of a need for the team than Meyer is?

and just wondering why u would have mezaros on the almost list and not barker. Barker had more points in less games and I agree Mezaros has a slight upside that barker. Hopefully you can change my mind between those 2 picks. Maybe watching one team more has turned me into a homer for the hat but Id really like to hear what u think.

It was just honorable mention man. Meszaros, Coburn, Barker, Weber...they're all great but didn't make my top 10.

Filiweich slightly over Meyer IMO. Not only did he pot 40 goals but he also had to carry 5'6'' Yellow Horn as well.

Orv
03-23-2005, 02:37 PM
Mezaros over Barker? Filewich over Meyer?
Not trying to be a tiger homer here but I have seen the tigers play probably more than anyother WHL team and right behind them would be Lethbridge. I know that Filewich had more points but I dont see him being better than Meyer this year. Ive seen Filewich more this year than Meyer and I agree Filewich had a breakout season but he isnt as much of a need for the team than Meyer is?

and just wondering why u would have mezaros on the almost list and not barker. Barker had more points in less games and I agree Mezaros has a slight upside that barker. Hopefully you can change my mind between those 2 picks. Maybe watching one team more has turned me into a homer for the hat but Id really like to hear what u think.

WHAT???

You've seen the Tigers the most yet you've seen Filewich more than Meyer?? Is it just me or does that not quite make sense.

Filewich has been awesome this year for the Hurricanes. As another poster said he carried little Yellow Horn. Yellow Horn is good but Filewich is the glue that holds the forwards together.

Greg7
03-24-2005, 01:30 AM
Phaneuf
Weber
Fehr
Dawes
Brule
Coburn
Stone
Meszaros
Seabrook
Gagnon
Price
Glass
Green

Not in exact order, not 10, just the top guys in my mind.

Whawks33
03-24-2005, 07:31 AM
No order, but top guys in my mind from this season:

Clayton Stoner
Braydon Coburn
Eric Fehr
Nigel Dawes
Shea Weber
Gilbert Brule
Clarke MacArthur
Mike Green
Dan Da Silva
Ryan Stone
Adam Courchaine

Goalies I'd say Jeff Glass was best, hands down.

Impressive rookies:

Zach Hamill, Andrej Meszaros, Michael Sauer, Michael Grabner, Derek Ryan

Nielson81
03-24-2005, 11:10 AM
in my mind here at the top 15...in no order

Eric Fehr
Dion Phanuef
Gilbert Brule
Ryan Stone
Bryan Bridges
Nigel Dawes
Kris Russel
Colton Yellowhorn
Jonathan Filewich
Jeff Glass
Stephan Meyer
Steven Later
Aaron Sorochan
Clark McArthur

Letang fan 58
03-28-2005, 06:25 PM
Top 10 for me this year

Eric Fehr
Dion Phaneuf
Shea Weber
Ryan Stone
Gilbert Brule
Jeff Glass
Colton Yellowhorn
Kris Russell
Steven Later
Nigel Dawes

Top Rook this year
Tyler Plante hands down

Top Dman
Dion Phaneuf

MVP
Eric Fehr