MLB Mock Evaluation Part IV: Best IF D

Who do you have patrolling your infield? Will it be a constant "Past a diving Jeter" for your pitching staff and Rafael Palmeiro being your only Gold Glover, or will you get the highlight reel major league D from the greats like Ozzie Smith and Larry Bowa?

This award, is appropriately named The Bill Buckner award.

ICW:
1B: Helton
2B: Loretta
SS: Furcal
3B: Lowell
C: Schneider

Bench:
C:Hernandez
2B/3B: Bellhorn
UTIL: Reese

FOTS:
3B Ramirez
SS Rollins
2B Alfonzo
1B Broussard
Freel
Walker
Vizquel
Zaun

Hercules:
Chone Figgins, 2B
Orlando Cabrera, SS
Troy Glaus, 3B
Justin Morneau, 1B
Bengie Molina, C
Jose Molina, C
Doug Mienkewicz, 1B
Adam Kennedy, 2B


Tuggy:
Juan Uribe, 2B
Bret Boone, DH
Eric Chavez, 3B
Albert Pujols, 1B
Bobby Crosby, SS
Mike Lieberthal, C
Brad Ausmus, C
Mike Sweeney, 1B/DH
Keith Ginter, INF


DynamoAO
C:Joe Mauer
1B: Derrek Lee
2B:Alfonso Soriano
3B:Alex Rodriguez
SS:Kazuo Matsui


Jared:
SS Michael Young
1B Mark Teixera
3B David Wright
C Johnny Estrada
2B Jose Reyes
C JD Closser
IF Mike Cuddyer
2B-SS-3B Desi Relaford
OF-IF Jose Macias

Dr Love
2B: Polanco
SS: Tejada
3B: Huff
C: Posada
1B: Konerko
C: Pieryznski
1B/LF: Klesko
IF: Valentin


Stanley:
3B: Dallas McPherson
SS: Khalil Greene
2B: Chase Utley
1B: Jim Thome
C: Michael Barrett

AtG:
1B: Jeff Bagwell
2B: Jeff Kent
SS: Derek Jeter
3B: Chipper Jones
C: Mike Piazza
Jason Giambi (1B)
Vinny Castilla(3B)
Shea Hillenbrand(3B)
Brad Inge


Roughneck:
1B: Richie Sexon
2B: Orlando Hudson
SS: Jack Wilson
3B: Scott Rolen
C: Jason Varitek

Winger98:
C: Javy Lopez
1B: Brad Wilkerson
2B: Luis Castillo
3B: Bill Mueller
SS: Carlos Guillen


Bauldie:
Melvin Mora (R)
Jason Kendall (R)
Adrian Beltre (L)
Cesar Izturis (S)
Tony Womack (L)
Carlos Delgado (L)

Monster_Bert:
Renteria SS
Green 1B
Rodriguez C
Vidro 2B
Koskie 3B

Islandnucker:
C-Paul LoDuca
1B-Darin Erstad
2B-Marcus Giles
3B-Hank Blalock
SS-Nomar Garciaparra

I have Aubrey Huff, I'm automatically out of the running.

I have Aubrey Huff, I'm automatically out of the running.

Paul Konerko is quite asstastic too.

Paul Konerko is quite asstastic too.
Yes he is. If I get the backups in there, I'll be alright. The middle IF is darn good though.

Starting lineup only, ICW's is the best IMO. Roughneck a close second.

But ICW does have Mark KHorn.

Starting lineup only, ICW's is the best IMO. Roughneck a close second.

But ICW does have Mark KHorn.

He will be DHing. Unless God himself intervenes, Mark Bellhorn will NOT be playing the field. Pokey is teh best defensive sub ever.

Roughneck's D is awesome. Rolen is sweet, and that middle IF is REALLY good with Hudson and Wilson. Varitek is a good battermate, but Sexson is so-so at 1B.

Btw, Dynamo:
Kazuo Matsui + Alfonso Soriano = WORST DOUBLE PLAY COMBINATION IMAGINABLE.

In terms of starters, Roughneck by quite a bit IMO. Hudson, Wilson, and Rolen are all great defensively, and Sexson and Varitek are pretty good as well.

With the back-ups, I definetely like my line-up, though. Cabrera's a GG, Glaus is decent defensively, and Kennedy and Meinkewicz are very awesome.

I think Hercules has the best.

Tuggy and very very easily.

Tuggy and very very easily.

That's what I like to hear :D

I think my IF D is as good as anyone elses.

That's what I like to hear :D

I think my IF D is as good as anyone elses.
is he going to receive his cash payment soon? will this go down as the tuggy if defence scandal?

Bump... and we'll just declare this thing a tie.

FOTS banned again? geez :joker:

FOTS banned again? geez :joker:

I wonder what happened.

Me. Pudge Rodriguez. ;)

Me. Pudge Rodriguez. ;)

Another example of "riding the reputation."

Brian Schneider owned all last year.