P Jiddy
09-26-2003, 12:20 PM
In a points only league (1 point for a goal, 1 point for an assist)Who wins this trade:
Team A gets:
Marian Gobarik and a mid 2nd round pick
Team B gets:
Simon Gagne, Justin Williams, a high 1st round picks
I am going for it this year but is giving up Gagne, Williams and the pick for Gobarik too good an offer to turn down??
Let me know!!
Porn*
09-26-2003, 12:24 PM
dude... i'd rather gagne, williams over gaborik alone anyday! And the high 1st is great too...
Big Bill
09-26-2003, 12:25 PM
dude... i'd rather gagne, williams over gaborik alone anyday! And the high 1st is great too...
I totally agree here. Gagne is due for a bounce back yr. Hitchcock thinks he should lead the team in pts this year. Plus williams is a very fine young hard working forward
Sorry but no way Gaborik outscores these two, especaially since he is in slovakia!
I would keep what you have got
BINGOV
09-26-2003, 12:33 PM
I totally agree here. Gagne is due for a bounce back yr. Hitchcock thinks he should lead the team in pts this year. Plus williams is a very fine young hard working forward
Sorry but no way Gaborik outscores these two, especaially since he is in slovakia!
I would keep what you have got
Agreed. Gagne will rebound this season. Gagne and Williams will out-produce Gaborik. Besides, it certainly seems that Gaborik and Wild management as destine for an acrimonious contract squabble.
Koltsov71
09-27-2003, 04:54 AM
I totally agree here. Gagne is due for a bounce back yr. Hitchcock thinks he should lead the team in pts this year. Plus williams is a very fine young hard working forward
Sorry but no way Gaborik outscores these two, especaially since he is in slovakia!
I would keep what you have got
Agreed.
Bring_Bak_Damphousse
09-27-2003, 09:27 PM
I think Marian Gaborik would have had a monster season. Especially after that playoff run. Gagne is good but I think Gaborik is much better But when you add in Williams the first and the fact that Gaboriks playing in Slovakia I`d take Gagne and Williams.
Robert Paulson*
09-28-2003, 08:11 AM
I totally agree here. Gagne is due for a bounce back yr. Hitchcock thinks he should lead the team in pts this year. Plus williams is a very fine young hard working forward
Sorry but no way Gaborik outscores these two, especaially since he is in slovakia!
I would keep what you have got
Yeah, what he said.. even if Gaborik was signed, I'd still take Gagne and Williams.