need to plug hole on 'D' - who to pick ?

Okay, if you read my other thread regarding injuries to Leetch, Stuart, and Mccabe...you will know my problem. So, this is what's left for me to pull off the heap. Who should I take? Just to plug the hole until Leetch or Stuart gets back. Some of these guys are probably better choices than Mccabe anyway. I can only take one. Points for goals, assists, and plus/minues. Penalty minutes count AGAINST me. Thanks !!

Alexander Khavanov, StL
Sean Hill, Car
Nathan Dempsey, Chi
Mike Rathje, SJ
Toni Lydman, Cgy
Frantisek Kaberle, Atl
Alexei Zhitnik, Buf
Eric Weinrich, Phi
Jonathan Girard, Bos
Jason York, Nsh
Craig Rivet, Mon
Brad Lukowich, TB
Bret Hedican, Car
Vladimir Malakhov, NYR
Glen Wesley, Car

I would likely go with Girard,he has the best mix,offense,he's on a decent team,and isn't spotted in the sin bin very often.

I would likely go with Girard,he has the best mix,offense,he's on a decent team,and isn't spotted in the sin bin very often.
Girard is hurt and is out for the season most likely, so don't go with him