![]() |
All Injury Talk: Gill out Saturday/Markov not back before California trip
Latest Updates:
Spacek - undisclosed - day-to-day - will miss Wed & Thurs games Gill - infection - day-to-day - released from hospital Nov 18, won't play Sat. Kostitsyn - groin - placed on IR Nov 16 Markov - knee - no set date for return - won't be back before California road trip (Nov. 30 - Dec. 3) per Martin White - sports hernia surgery - won't be back until after Christmas per Martin (Nov. 9) Campoli - hamstring/tendon - skated alone Nov. 8 Nov. 18 Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Nov. 16 Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Nov. 9 Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Oct. 26 Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Will Markov be able to start right away? How is his conditioning? Has he somehow practiced lately?
|
Quote:
I wouldn't worry about conditioning. |
Markov will play. Get injured. Never play again.
|
Markov will not get hurt the rest of the year and become a savior.
|
Markov better not come early again. He should take all the time in the world, make sure it's healed properly.
|
It is concerning that Markov is going to see Dr. Andrews again tomorrow given that he saw him 1 week ago.
What has changed in 1 week that he has to return to see Dr. Andrews? Let's hope it is for final clearance...but it doesn't all add up right now. |
Nothing adds up right now because we're not given any data to add.
All this speculation/rumour mongering/predictions of doom is the result of the admin's hush-hush attitude towards Markov's health. When you say nothing and keep his condition secret, when you dismiss questions on his return to a simplistic, "He's making progress", then don't be surprised that people will assume the worst. And yes, the team DOES owe it to us, the fans, to feed us updates. It's not like we're voyeurs into someone's personal drama; this is a business that lives and dies on its entertainment value to us. We create the revenue that ultimately pays Markov's salary -- kindly have the respect to give us good news and bad news on a key reason I paid good money for tickets. |
Quote:
You've been told enough already. They've reported when he stopped skating, Martin gave an update a few weeks ago giving a rough but very vague approximation. You've recieved news about when he last went to the doctor. You know that he's going to the doctor tomorrow as well. How about you just stay patient and stop acting so spoiled. You're lucky you even get any of this info at all. Some of you would have died if you'd have to live in the 50s and 60s without internet and tv where communication was slower. |
Quote:
Seriously now, whether you recognize it or not, we are the customers of the Habs. They owe us information because, ultimately, they owe us their business. The Montreal Canadiens aren't entitled to our ticket money, nor are they entitled to ad revenue. They command their high prices only as long as we hold them in high regard. You may not remember this, but there were many years in the 90s and early 2000s where the team was NOT doing well, where they had to scramble to sell tickets. Wanted to see a game? There were lots of empty seats to choose from. They spent a fortune marketing themselves to the fans, recreating the organization's image into the user-friendly city-wide phenomenon it is today. Bottom line: They gave us what we wanted and we bought the product. These are the same rules that apply to any business, ESPECIALLY one in the entertainment industry. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The object is to win games... if the team feels that there is an advantage in not letting your opponents know the exact injury status of players (and tons of teams believe this) so be it. |
Quote:
Face it, the reason the organization has prospered even without a Cup is because it figured out how to sell itself as a culture. Before the mid-90s, all they had to do was win Stanley Cup after Stanley Cup. Then the well went dry and so did ticket sales. The on ice product -- the 'show' -- simply wasn't enough anymore because the team simply wasn't that good. So in comes the new admin and voila -- a new marketing philosophy. The Canadiens started marketing individual players, showing up on billboards, showing up at events -- the whole culture thing. And we, the fans, responded. In fact, we responded so well that some people actually believe it's wrong to have expectations of the organization, that they don't owe us anything. You couldn't be more wrong. The Montreal Canadiens are a sports franchise that uses its rich history as a terrific marketing tool to keep us hooked. They need us more than we need them. See the Montreal Expos for further evidence. Am I complaining about this manipulative relationship? No, because that's how business works. I'm happy to spend my money on tickets and don't feel used or betrayed -- as long as I'm entertained, which I have been for over 40 years. Please don't pretend that my questioning the brass means a lack of support. If being critical of management means a lack of support, then about 80% of the threads on this board are in the same boat. We've all bought into the hockey culture that exists on the ice, and off, and we're entitled to sound off anyway we want. We're all fans of the team... as long as the team is smart enough to be fans of us. Quote:
The second part misses my point. I'm not personally miffed at the organization, I'm just stating the reason why so many people here keep harping on this subject. Look at the number of posts on Markov and ask yourself why so many fans are frustrated and distrustful. The reason, I think, is because the team has created the idea that the team is 'ours', but then goes dark about its biggest star. I tried to explain why you can't consciously create the most loyal fanbase in the league and then withhold information from it. It's a tricky contradiction that can bite you in the ass. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
It's not like there's a shortage of the kind of people they cater to. |
You would think that even at 100 % healthy that Markov would play the first few games with a knee brace
|
Quote:
I don't see an actual impact on the club's revenue streams stemming from dissatisfaction over injury information. And the team has an interest in keeping injury disclosure to a minimum to limit other teams gamesmanship on injuries. There's a reason coaches prefer to limit their briefings to terms like upper/lower body injury. I think the desire to protect their players outweighs your desire to be feel "in the loop." |
Quote:
Not so with entertainment; for better or worse, we want anti-secrecy. The movies? Geez, the studios will do anything to spoon-feed us info, keeping us tuned in to its product long, long before the product is even in theaters. Secrecy - what secrecy? We get a never-ending stream of breadcrumbs sprinkled in print, TV and online, all leading to the release date -- previews, interviews, exclusive behind-the-scenes glimpses, photo shoots, etc, etc, etc -- all of it designed to keep us up to date on the upcoming feature. The real secrecy stuff always comes out, and is poison -- see Megan Fox, Charlie Sheen or Mel Gibson. Sports is the same. If there's one thing MLB learned -- the hard way with steroids -- it's that secrecy always comes out, and the fans will lambaste you for trying to fool them. I'm not saying a rehabbing Markov is anywhere near the severity of a Roger Clemens or Barry Bonds, or that we have to be wired to Markov's biorhythms to keep tabs on whether he slept well. I'm just sayin' we've moved beyond the time when secrecy was an accepted form of communication for most businesses. Wanna' be secret? Good luck, when every damn hotel and restaurant is laid bare for review on the internet; every actor does a gazillion promo interviews to plug his latest film to the fans; and every athlete exposes the state of his health to the fans who ultimately pay his multi-million dollar salary. Right or wrong, anyone who makes money entertaining the public owes that public transparency. |
I'm sorry, didn't I click the injury report thread? Sure doesn't look like it!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
This isn't the 50's or 60's, so it doesn't matter what it was like then. This is the now. The reality is, we didn't get an update or a vague approximation. We got a BS answer that he's on plan but then since then, everyone refuses to answer what is the plan. That isn't an update, that is skirting the issue and not answering. The reality is, NHL teams are required to report certain things to the media, its part of the NHL rules. So don't claim we are spoiled, we aren't, it is what it is. |
Quote:
We are spoiled though. Yes there is a requirement but in more than half the markets hockey is an afterthought, and teams only have 1 or 2 guys who focus exclusively on its coverage, if that many. I try to find out the injury situation of a day to day player for my pool, if Yahoo doesn't know than nobody does. With the Habs you get 20 journalists on twitter immediately posting all rumors, speculations, and quotes as soon as they come out, in two languages. Does that mean the club should try and hide things from us? No, and I hope they don't, but they should be putting the players interest first even if it means not updating us 24/7. |
Quote:
seriously... |
Quote:
He was on Sportsnet's Hockey Central and he said that Markov was in Florida to see his doctors, he was cleared to resume skating and he was expected to practice before the end of the month. The fact is, if the team had an exact date, they'd give it to us... But guess what? They don't have an exact date. The situation changes daily. How Markov's knee responds, how sore it is, how much swelling we see, etc... in the hours and day that follows any vigorous workout has an effect. This is a fluid situation, and at the same time the team risks over exposure if they do a press release every time every player feels a twinge of pain, or gets a therapy massage. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:03 AM. |
vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.