John Carlson or Kevin Stattenkirk
 

Who will be better

Shattenkirk

Carlson. I'm a big Shattenkirk fan, but Carlson's defensive upside is miles ahead of Shatty's. And their offensive potential is pretty similar. It's very realistic Carlson could be a Norris contender.

carlson, much better defensively

Can't decide. I'm too torn.

Definitely Carlson.

Carlson.

Could change on any given day.

Hard choice considering Carlson has never been on PP1.

The American

Carlson

Carlson

John Carlson. Dude is underrated.

Shattenkirk.

Carlson.

Carlson without a doubt. Closer to Pietrangelo than Shattenkirk imo.

Just noticed the typo in the heading.

Stattenkirk solid typo imo.

This one literally busted my balls but I have to go with Carlson.

Shattenkirk... I don't see anything more than a 3-4 guy in Carlson

well he's already a #2 guy, so so much for your vision

It's a tough call I do think Carlson has more upside. Shattenkirk's defense is underrated though. He's actually solid defensively except against LA last year lol.

Carlson is already the caps #2 and very well could surpass Green

Close, but Shattenkirk.

Johnny Carls.

And boy do you like making threads eh PG?

Carlson.

Very good defensively, better than Shattenkirk (not a knock on KS)

Carlson.