HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   Ottawa Senators (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   B-Sens First-Quarter Grades (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=1301957)

BingoSensFan 12-05-2012 09:39 PM

B-Sens First-Quarter Grades
 
Hello, friends. This year’s Binghamton Senators are deserving of the highest grades ever issued, as they have put on display one of the greatest first-quarter performances in Binghamton hockey history. They are currently riding an eight-game winning streak and the mood around the team is predictably jovial. First-year head coach Luke Richardson merits a great deal of credit in establishing an atmosphere imbued with passion, respect and discipline, with teamwork being a focal point. The players take to heart every word uttered by Richardson, making him the ideal coach in this particular environment. The following evaluations reflect my opinion only.

#2 Eric Gryba, A-. The same knock against him still exists – not taking full advantage of his size – but he is handling the puck and making decisions in his own end better than he has in a while. He was troubled by an injury earlier, but has returned to complete health and is showing signs of the form he exhibited in his rookie season.

#3 Fredrik Claesson, A-. As always, grades for a 19-year old player in the American Hockey League, especially a European, are largely irrelevant. Not much can be discerned from a player’s performance at this age; it should be viewed as simply an experimental season. A player could have a wonderful season at this stage or a poor one and it may not be indicative of future success or failure. NHLers Steve Mason and Joe Thornton are converse examples of how a career can suddenly take a different path. That being said, the young, Swedish defenseman has adjusted swimmingly to an entirely new culture and style of play. He has embraced the physical aspect of the game, no doubt influenced by the tutelage of Richardson, as most of the blueline corps has done likewise. Perhaps most impressive is the fact that he has not once looked intimidated, though Richardson and assistant coach Steve Stirling are careful not to expose him too much.

#5 Mark Borowiecki, A. Some have expressed concern regarding his high penalty minute total, but that number has come mostly as a result of fighting majors, which themselves have been borne of a desire to come to the aid of teammates. He is the ultimate team player and competitor. One of the strongest and most menacing players in the league, he will probably be in the NHL when that league resumes and may never return to the AHL. He will be an immense fan favorite in Ottawa for years to come.

#6 Chris Wideman, I. He gets an incomplete grade, having appeared in only six contests thus far. In that brief time, he has shown some nice offensive instincts, but has been in over his head defensively. There was some speculation that Claesson made the team ahead of him simply because of his nationality, but that could not be further from the truth. Wideman has more to work on in Elmira before taking on a larger role with Binghamton.

#10 Jean-Gabriel Pageau, B+. He is another 19 year-old who should not be judged harshly. He was slow to warm to the league, but has stepped up his play considerably. He could be well on his way toward making a name for himself, but there is a long way to go for him. For a player of his small stature and young age, he has proven to be quite feisty and adept at handling his own. Don’t expect big offensive production from him yet – he is the only regular forward on the team without a goal – but the tools are there for future success in that department.

#12 Pat Cannone, B+. He is what he is, which is a solid defensive player who can occasionally contribute at the other end of the ice. His prospects for the NHL are slim, but he is a serviceable player at this level and a pretty good “glue guy” to have a on a club.

#15 Cole Schneider, A-. He has displayed some rather surprising offensive talent, but his bread and butter will be working the corners and cycling the puck for more talented line-mates. He appears to have found a home after being shuffled in and out of the lineup in the early going. He is the type of player that would be comfortable being inserted on any forward unit.

#16 Mark Stone, A. He possesses exceptionally good hockey sense, which will undoubtedly be his ticket to the next level. His skating will always be a flaw, but he is the rare player who will be more successful in the NHL than in the AHL. He has the ability to make a play when seemingly none exists. As the smartest player on the team, his future looks bright if he continues to work hard.

#17 Patrick Wiercioch, A. He has finally taken the advice to prepare better in the off-season to heart and has reaped the rewards. Every single facet of his game has improved greatly. If a career in the NHL was in question before, that may no longer be the case. In his prior two seasons, he showed an absolute disregard for shooting the puck, likely caused by his lack of upper-body strength. This season, he fires the puck from anywhere, revealing an accurate shot previously hidden. In his own zone, his added muscle has also enabled him to ward off defenders with one hand while playing the puck with the other, a skill most defensemen utilize but one that he could not in the past.

#18 Shane Prince, A. Of all the players on this team that are at that ripe age of 19, he has been the most impressive. A fantastic hockey player, if he does continue on this path, he will be a surefire NHLer despite his diminutive stature. He is dripping with abilities that cannot be taught and is only getting better as the season progresses. Skating, stickhandling, awareness, shooting, passing, toughness – he is the complete package. He has the potential to be a draft day steal at #61.

#19 Hugh Jessiman, C+. He needs to decide what kind of player he wants to be, but it may be too late at this point in his career. He could produce offensively if he drove to the net more. He could be a bit of an enforcer if he dropped the gloves more. He could be a shift disturber if he became more involved. He has the ability to be any of these things, but he is stuck in a sort of “no-man’s land” and can’t seem to get out.

#20 Andre Petersson, C-. He has under-performed the most of any player on the team. Last year, he was good on a bad team. This year, he has been just okay on a good team. Talent is not the question. Persistence and drive are the sticking points when discussing his game. He is on the small side, but is shifty and slippery enough to overcome that – if he really wants to. The rest of the season could be pivotal to his development.

#21 Derek Grant, A. It’s amazing what a little confidence can do for a guy. He has evolved into an unlikely go-to scorer on the team in the first part of the season. His short-handed prowess has been remarkable. He is much more energized than last season and his first step is tremendously improved.

#22 David Dziurzynski, A-. He had a wonderful start to the campaign and has tailed off a bit recently, but is still contributing to the team in various ways. He continues to be one of the hardest hitters on the team. A career in the NHL is probably a long shot, but it could happen if he develops a bit of an offensive bent to his game.

#23 Corey Cowick, B+. He has made great strides from last season, but is still prone to standing still and being a spectator at times. It would be nice to see him be a more imposing force, as he has the size and speed to be a great presence on the forecheck.

#24 Stephane Da Costa, I. He has major-league skill with a sometimes minor-league effort level. He’s only played six games, so it would be unfair to analyze his performance. He struggled early with a variety of physical ailments, but recently had a hat trick (which was really a four-goal game). Offensive outbursts are welcome, but all the organization is looking for from him is consistency, which he has failed to achieve up to this point.

#27 Mike Hoffman, A. He has everything needed to be successful – he is the best skater and puck-handler on the team and plays a surprisingly physical style – except he lacks hockey IQ. He would have been in the NHL last season if he possessed better instincts. He might yet still make it in the NHL, but his hockey sense may forever be a question mark.

#29 Tyler Eckford, A-. The only thing hurting his grade is a few defensive lapses; otherwise, he has been one of the most pleasant surprises on the team. He has a blistering shot from the point that is both heavy and accurate. He is also very smart about keeping it low when necessary and taking a little off of it if the situation calls for it. He and Andre Benoit make for great power play quarterbacks.

#30 Ben Bishop, B+. Aside from one or two games in which he would say he was less than stellar, his play has been just fine. For now, the team is blessed to have an abundance of quality netminding, with the top two being great positional goaltenders. He has benefited from solid team defense, but has also been there for the rare breakdown.

#33 Jakob Silfverberg, A. He has surpassed all expectations. He has fully embraced the North American style and everything that comes along with it. His comportment has been better than anyone could have possibly imagined. As for his on-ice exploits, there isn’t much to criticize. He has a lethal wrist shot, a powerful stride, he knows where everyone is on the ice, he kills penalties and he has even become more involved along the walls. A long life in the NHL is inevitable.

#40 Robin Lehner, A. Even though the reasons for team success are plentiful, he is the most valuable player of the first quarter. When a player of his ability comes in with the right attitude and focus, success is a given. He may have to spend the rest of the season in Binghamton regardless of the outcome of the lockout, but it’s fair to say he may now be ready for at least a backup role in Ottawa. The only aspect of his game that could use some work involves his playing of the puck; it remains the only time he appears unsure of himself on the ice.

#61 Andre Benoit, A. If he were just a little bigger and a little quicker, he would be the incarnation of a young Wade Redden. It would be an injustice if he never got another shot at the highest level. He is the perfect captain and easily one of the most critical elements of this hockey club. It would not be a stretch to refer to him as one of the best defensemen in the league.

#93 Mika Zibanejad, B+. He has received a degree of criticism during his first exposure to the league, but most of it is unfair. He has had a few ups and downs already, but he will be just fine. The reasons for his being highly regarded are clearly evident. He is a big, strong kid who is a very good skater and playmaker. Expectations of him may be a bit pronounced, but he could be a good player for a long time. The only true negative evaluation of him as yet may be his conditioning. He was clearly not ready for long weekends and seems to get fatigued late in games.

Minister of Offence 12-05-2012 09:44 PM

Me thinks the hockey ppl of Binghamton are quite happy these days.

You lose, Huge Specimen.

Shane Prince is a baller though, true say. He's gonna keep going.

CanadianHockey 12-05-2012 09:47 PM

I'm reluctant to say Boro deserves an A. He struggled early with some dumb mistakes in his own end, and for a time was getting outplayed defensively by Claesson and Eckford. Based on giving Eckford an A- for inconsistent defensive play, I'd be inclined to give Boro an A- as well.

Minister of Offence 12-05-2012 09:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CanadianHockey (Post 56282991)
I'm reluctant to say Boro deserves an A. He struggled early with some dumb mistakes in his own end, and for a time was getting outplayed defensively by Claesson and Eckford. Based on giving Eckford an A- for inconsistent defensive play, I'd be inclined to give Boro an A- as well.

There's a couple too many A's there IMO.

But had they been 5-15 or something there'd be too many F's and D's.

But damn, just give Lehner that A+!!!!

SensPromo 12-05-2012 09:52 PM

Some of the ranks seem a little too positive, Cowick, DD, Hoffman and Boro imo should have been a grade lower. Overall was good though, and liked the writeups!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Minister of Offence (Post 56283115)
There's a couple too many A's there IMO.

But had they been 5-15 or something there'd be too many F's and D's.

But damn, just give Lehner that A+!!!!

As long as he is behind Brust it's only an A. No A+'s for 2nd place!

Dionysus 12-05-2012 09:53 PM

Thanks for in-depth evaluations! It has been fun to watch bingo this year, exciting brand of hockey and some great young players.

ATdaisuki 12-05-2012 09:54 PM

i think you are rather generous with these grades. the team has done well as a unit, but individually (which i believe the grades are supposed to be based on) some players have not exceeded expectations, but have simply met them, with the exception of a few players. overall i agree with most of your write ups though, just would have lowered some grades.
one write up i do want to touch on is hoffman's. i've only seen him in small bursts over the past years, but i've been watching a lot of games this season and i don't think he's lacking in the hockey sense (hockey i.q.) department. he looks like a wizard out there sometimes, though he also tries to do too at some points. you've obviously seen more of him than i have, so i'll have to keep my eyes on him in the upcoming games and see.
good job.

Lehner 12-05-2012 10:05 PM

Way Too Generous,

There is no way Boro should get an "A". Just to start out.

Anyways Im not going to do a explanation for them all but here are my grades:

#2 Eric Gryba, B+

#3 Fredrik Claesson, A-

#5 Mark Borowiecki, C+

#10 Jean-Gabriel Pageau, B

#12 Pat Cannone, B

#15 Cole Schneider, A-

#16 Mark Stone, A-

#17 Patrick Wiercioch, A+

#18 Shane Prince, A-

#19 Hugh Jessiman, B-

#20 Andre Petersson, D+

#21 Derek Grant, A

#22 David Dziurzynski, B+

#23 Corey Cowick, B-

#24 Stephane Da Costa, A-

#27 Mike Hoffman, B+

#29 Tyler Eckford, A

#30 Ben Bishop, B+

#33 Jakob Silfverberg, B+, I wanted to see more from silfv but he is getting into his groove now.

#40 Robin Lehner, A+

#61 Andre Benoit, A

#93 Mika Zibanejad, B-

Very well written tho, thx.

source 12-05-2012 10:13 PM

Always love reading your write-ups. Keep 'em coming.

Stone is a hockey genius.

Minister of Offence 12-05-2012 10:20 PM

Well written, I should say.

Ski 12-05-2012 10:50 PM

Good write up BSF..

Some of you guys need to understand that this team we have has been the real deal and we are really genuine excited..hard not to when we are going for a club record 9 wins in a row this Friday night and in the mix of a difficult East division for the first time in a long while..

Minister of Offence 12-05-2012 10:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ski (Post 56285539)
Good write up BSF..

Some of you guys need to understand that this team we have has been the real deal and we are really genuine excited..hard not to when we are going for a club record 9 wins in a row this Friday night and in the mix of a difficult East division for the first time in a long while..

It's the same type of wave that you see in the Zibanejad thread, just the opposite.

Samsquanch 12-05-2012 11:35 PM

Excellent read, very much appreciated :handclap:

I cant help but believe the ratings may be a tad high, but the writes up are great regardless. Very hopeful the team continues to ride this wave of success, and if a few of those guys pick up their game a bit, they could very well be contenders.

saskriders 12-06-2012 12:19 AM

I think I've missed too many games to give a fair ratings, but the one player I know

Lehner A+

Ski 12-06-2012 12:31 AM

I will also like to add that Bingo has the best win percentage in the AHL..

3 out of top 5 come from the East..

Binghamton Senators 18 12 4 1 1 26 0.722
Abbotsford Heat 22 13 4 3 2 31 0.705
Springfield Falcons 20 12 4 1 3 28 0.700
Syracuse Crunch 20 13 5 1 1 28 0.700
Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Penguins 20 13 7 0 0 26 0.650

---------
http://theahl.com/stats/statdisplay.php?type=standings

ReginKarlssonLehner 12-06-2012 12:46 AM

#2 Eric Gryba, B

#3 Fredrik Claesson, A

#5 Mark Borowiecki, C+

#10 Jean-Gabriel Pageau, B

#12 Pat Cannone, B+

#15 Cole Schneider, A-

#16 Mark Stone, A-

#17 Patrick Wiercioch, A+

#18 Shane Prince, A

#19 Hugh Jessiman, B-

#20 Andre Petersson, C-

#21 Derek Grant, A

#22 David Dziurzynski, B

#23 Corey Cowick, B-

#24 Stephane Da Costa, A-

#27 Mike Hoffman, B+

#29 Tyler Eckford, A-

#30 Ben Bishop, B+

#33 Jakob Silfverberg, A+

#40 ROBIN LEHNER, A+

#61 Andre Benoit, A

#93 Mika Zibanejad, B

MoreGore 12-06-2012 07:42 AM

I certainly appreciate the work and results. I read the whole thing and enjoyed it thoroughly.

Thanks.

leftwinglocker 12-06-2012 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CanadianHockey (Post 56282991)
I'm reluctant to say Boro deserves an A. He struggled early with some dumb mistakes in his own end, and for a time was getting outplayed defensively by Claesson and Eckford. Based on giving Eckford an A- for inconsistent defensive play, I'd be inclined to give Boro an A- as well.

Clarkson alum/Philly fan here ... Great write up. Please, please, please send us Boro. Some of you don't appreciate what you have (I think your coach does though). You win playoff rounds with guys like this. Took in a couple of recent games. Noticed they are now spotting him on the PP in addition to handling full 2 min PK shifts. Exactly the curve they put him on in Clarkson.

sg58 12-06-2012 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Minister of Offence (Post 56285603)
It's the same type of wave that you see in the Zibanejad thread, just the opposite.

Wouldn't that be if someone kept saying Bingo would win their division even if they kept losing? ;)

In all seriousness, though, nice write-up. As many have pointed out, Boro might not deserve to be with the top graded.

tenpinsplit 12-06-2012 11:42 AM

imo lehner doesnt deserve an a+. he was goaded into a fight with syracuse with a large lead and it ultimately lead to losing the game. if it was simply his play it would be an a+ but he needs to be stronger mentally.

Senatorsfan90 12-06-2012 01:00 PM

^
That loss was not on Lehner. Lawson was atrocious, no one can blame a goalie with a 5-0 lead in the less then half a game being confident his team can hold the lead.

Minister of Offence 12-06-2012 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by toe2toe (Post 56298665)
imo lehner doesnt deserve an a+. he was goaded into a fight with syracuse with a large lead and it ultimately lead to losing the game. if it was simply his play it would be an a+ but he needs to be stronger mentally.

He's not god, and I'm not sure even god would have foreseen Nathan Lawson playing the way he did in relief.

moz 12-06-2012 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by toe2toe (Post 56298665)
imo lehner doesnt deserve an a+. he was goaded into a fight with syracuse with a large lead and it ultimately lead to losing the game. if it was simply his play it would be an a+ but he needs to be stronger mentally.

That justifies an F for Lawson more than it does a non-A+ for Lehner...

SixthSens 12-06-2012 01:32 PM

Great read as always, BSF.

SenzZen 12-06-2012 01:53 PM

Thanks BSF.

I appreciated and enjoyed the read, and the effort.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:10 PM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.