HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   Montreal Canadiens (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Personal draft grade 2012 reviewed. (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=1475071)

LeHaboholique 07-24-2013 10:15 PM

Personal draft grade 2012 reviewed.
 
Okay, last year I released a thread that asked you folks what you felt the player grades for the players specific to the 2012 draft. This year on the other hand, I would like for you all to expand on last year and tell me what you would like to rate them now based on an other year of work on the ice.



For you who like to look at your old handy grading. ----------> http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/sh...=lehaboholique

Alexdaman 07-24-2013 10:36 PM

Galchenyuk 9.0 B
Collberg 8.0 C
Thrower 7.0 C
Bozon 7.5 D
Vail 6.5 C
Hudon 7.5 C
Nystrom 6.5 C

Kensai Akatsume Ryu 07-24-2013 10:43 PM

Galchenyuk 9.0 B
Collberg 8.0 C
Thrower 7.0 D
Bozon 7.5 C
Vail 6.5 B
Hudon 7.5 C
Nystrom 7.0 D

AJMHABS 07-24-2013 11:15 PM

Galchenyuk 9.0 B
Collberg 8.0 C
Thrower 7.0 D
Bozon 7.5 D
Vail 6.5 B
Hudon 7.5 C
Nystrom 6.5 C

JonathanToews19clutc* 07-24-2013 11:16 PM

A.Galchenyuk ---> 9.0/8.5 B.
S.Collberg ---> 7.5 B.
D.Thrower ---> 7.0 C.
T.Bozon ---> 7.5 D.
B.Vail ---> 6.5 B.
C.Hudon ---> 7.5 C.
E.Nystrom ---> ... 6.5 C/D.

MD thaivuN 07-24-2013 11:42 PM

Galchenyuk: 9.0C
Collberg: 7.5B
Thrower: 6.5C
Bozon: 7.5D
Vail: 6.5B
Hudon: 7.5C
Nystrom: 7.0D

NewHabsEra* 07-24-2013 11:55 PM

Galchenyuk 8.5 B

Collberg 7.5 C

Thrower 6.5 D

Bozon 7 C

Vail 6 C

Hudon 7 C

Nystrom 7 D

Ezpz 07-25-2013 12:14 AM

Galchenyuk 9.0B
Collberg 8.5D(maybe I'm a little high on him, I think he's our best prospect)
Thrower 7.0D
Bozon 7.5C
Vail 6.0B
Hudon 8.0D
Nystrom 7.0D

Overall great draft.

Jabba11 07-25-2013 12:24 AM

Alex Galchenyuk 9.0B
Sebastian Collberg 7.5C
Dalton Thrower 7.5C
Tim Bozon 7.0C
Brady Vail 6.0C
Charles Hudon 7.5D
Erik Nystrom 7.5C

Kensai Akatsume Ryu 07-25-2013 12:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ezpz (Post 69588105)
Galchenyuk 9.0B
Collberg 8.5D(maybe I'm a little high on him, I think he's our best prospect)
Thrower 7.0D
Bozon 7.5C
Vail 6.0B
Hudon 8.0D
Nystrom 7.0D

Overall great draft.

Yours looks like mine. I see similar upside with Hudon and Collberg, was hesitant to label him a 8, and D a too. To me he's a very safe bet. Although, I ain't sure if his speed will be sufficient for him to reach "8" status... but he might improve it, so it's not impossible at all for him to be a first liner. I see him a bit like Patrice Bergeron personally, overall great player due to very high IQ. Regarding Collberg, I am not sure yet about the .5 extra... He has not shown dominance with adults yet, while Gally did. To me, that's the difference between a 8 and a 9... the gamebreaking and dominating ability. While I believe Collberg will be a great offensive force, I ain't sure he'll be great enough to be an elite in the NHL, hence my hesitation to go further than 8 for him. What do you think?

Kensai Akatsume Ryu 07-25-2013 12:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jabba11 (Post 69588353)
Alex Galchenyuk 9.0B
Sebastian Collberg 7.5C
Dalton Thrower 7.5C
Tim Bozon 7.0C
Brady Vail 6.0C
Charles Hudon 7.5D
Erik Nystrom 7.5C

Regarding Hudon's rating, compared to Thrower's, what makes you think, after their draft+1 seasons, that Hudon has a less likely chance to reach his potential, compared to Thrower? To me it would seem they both had very different seasons (Thrower being the horrible season, and Hudon the excellent season)... looking forward your input =)

Zaide 07-25-2013 01:20 AM

Galchenyuk 8.5 B
Collberg 8.0 D
Thrower 7.0 C
Bozon 7.5 D
Vail 6.5 B
Hudon 7.0 C
Nystrom 6.5 C

vokiel 07-25-2013 07:45 AM

No need to review what I gave...

That Habs Fan 07-25-2013 07:57 AM

Galchenyuk 9.0 B
Collberg 8.0 C
Thrower 7.5 C
Bozon 7.5 D
Vail 6.5 B
Hudon 7.0 C
Nystrom 6.5 C

Dagistitsyn 07-25-2013 08:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kensai Akatsume Ryu (Post 69585701)
Galchenyuk 9.0 B
Collberg 8.0 C
Thrower 7.0 D
Bozon 7.5 C
Vail 6.5 B
Hudon 7.5 C
Nystrom 7.0 D

This ^.

Edit: Nevermind. Galchenyuk an 8.5 B.

Kensai Akatsume Ryu 07-25-2013 08:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vokiel (Post 69592625)
No need to review what I gave...

Not a matter of needing, more like a matter of discussing :P

NH57 07-25-2013 08:37 AM

Galchenyuk: 8.5 C --> 9.0 B
Collberg: 8.0 D --> 7.5 B
Thrower: 7.0 C --> 7.0 C
Bozon: 7.5 D --> 7.5 C
Vail: 6.5 C --> 6.5 B
Hudon: 7.5 D --> 7.5 C
Nystrom: 6.5 C --> 6.5 B

Habaddict 07-25-2013 11:28 AM

Galchenyuk 8.5 A (No prospect is a lock. But if being productive in the NHL at
18 isn't an "A", what is?)

Collberg 7.5 C

Thrower 6 D

Bozon 7.5 D

Vail 6 C

Hudon 7 C

Nystrom 6.5 D

Redux91 07-25-2013 12:02 PM

everyone putting thrower at 7.5 and 7 is really mindblowing

if anything he really regressed this year to a 6.5 or 6

everyone elses ratings are pretty concensus i think, my only "iffy" would be is collberg a 8 or a 7.5, wont know till AHL

Kass Attack 07-25-2013 12:13 PM

Galchenyuk - 9.0C
Collberg - 7.5D
Thrower - 7.0C
Bozon: 7.0C
Vail: 6.0C
Hudon - 7.0C
Nystrom... who knows

Chris Cutter 07-25-2013 01:06 PM

Galchenyuk 8.5B...8.5A
Collberg 7.5B...7.5B
Thrower 7.5C...7C
Bozon 7C...7C
Vail 6B...6B
Hudon 6.5C...7.5D
Nystrom 7C...7C

dackelljuneaubulis02 07-25-2013 01:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ezpz (Post 69588105)
Galchenyuk 9.0B
Collberg 8.5D(maybe I'm a little high on him, I think he's our best prospect)
Thrower 7.0D
Bozon 7.5C
Vail 6.0B
Hudon 8.0D
Nystrom 7.0D

Overall great draft.

Love it! I think Hudon deserves an 8 though I can see why he isn't, hence the D! He has tons of potential.

Haven't seen much of Collberg so I don't know about the 8.5. If that would happen that would be amazing.

I think Vail's a 6.5 borderline 7. I only saw a bit of him but I was surprised how good he was with the puck for a prospect with little projected offensive upside.

Seriously I'm tempted to give Galchenyuk a 9.5C. I really think he can crack that inner circle of Datsuyk, Malkin, Tavares, Stamkos and that other jagoff.

Myron Gaines* 07-25-2013 01:38 PM

Galchenyuk 9C
Collberg 8C
Thrower 7D
Bozon 7.5C
Vail 6B
Hudon 7.5C
Nystrom 6C

montreal 07-25-2013 02:56 PM

Here's what I ranked after the draft,

Quote:

Originally Posted by montreal (Post 53218407)
Galchenyuk : 9.0 B
Collberg : 7.5 C
Thrower : 6.5 B
Bozon : 7.0 D
Vail : 6.5 B
Hudon : 7.0 D
Nystrom : 6.0 C

As of today,

Galchenyuk : 9.0 B
Collberg : 8 C
Thrower : 6.5 D
Bozon : 7 C
Vail : 6 C
Hudon : 8 D
Nystrom : 6 D

RustySpoon 07-25-2013 05:17 PM

Galchenyuk 8.5 B
Collberg 8.0 C
Thrower 7.0 C
Bozon 7.5 D
Vail 6.5 C
Hudon 7.5 C
Nystrom 6.0 C


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:41 AM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.