HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   Montreal Canadiens (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Top 10 Neglected Habs (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=1546517)

kingdok 11-26-2013 12:16 PM

Top 10 Neglected Habs
 
Top 10 players who don't have their jersey retired by the Habs

1- Newsy Lalonde
2- Toe Blake
3- Bill Durnan
4- Aurel Joliat
5- Georges Vezina
6- Guy Lapointe
7- Steve Shutt
8- George Hainsworth
9- Jacques Lemaire
10- JC Tremblay

HM Koivu, Mahovlich, Laperrière, Ferguson, Carbonneau, Pitre, Boucher

Tyson 11-26-2013 12:19 PM

Simply put, you can't retire everyone's number. I think Toe Blake should never be forgotten and his name and number should be in the rafters.

MXD 11-26-2013 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TGV (Post 75054123)
Top 10 players who don't have their jersey retired by the Habs

1- Newsy Lalonde
2- Toe Blake
3- Bill Durnan
4- Aurel Joliat
5- Georges Vezina
6- Guy Lapointe
7- Steve Shutt
8- George Hainsworth
9- Jacques Lemaire
10- JC Tremblay

HM Koivu, Mahovlich, Laperrière, Ferguson, Carbonneau, Pitre, Boucher

Joliat is...well, sort of retired.

I expected something a bit more insightful, like, Provost, Johnson Mantha (Silvio) and Reardon. And... Boucher ? Billy ? Yikes.

Edit - Blake, obviously.

kingdok 11-26-2013 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MXD (Post 75056969)
Joliat is...well, sort of retired.

I expected something a bit more insightful, like, Provost, Johnson Mantha (Silvio) and Reardon. And... Boucher ? Billy ? Yikes.

Edit - Blake, obviously.

Mantha is an omission and should get an HM. Reardon was great but not jersey retired great. Boucher was the team best player for years (edit: looking at stats, I might have overrated him, I guess he goes alongside Morenz and Joliat too well...)

Anyway, you're invited to do your top 10 too. :)

Seb 11-26-2013 01:27 PM

1) Saku

2) The rest

Pricef 11-26-2013 03:05 PM

How Vezina's number isn't yet retired is just baffling.

idk 11-26-2013 03:06 PM

The minimum requirement to have your number retired by the Canadiens should be to have your name in the Hall of Fame. That disqualifies J.C. Tremblay, Koivu (I don't foresee him making the HHoF), Little M, Ferguson, Carbonneau and Boucher. As for the others:

Lalonde: A very good player, but left the team under bad circumstances. Fought with his coach and with the owners and was unceremoniously dumped for nothing (an unknown prospect at the time named Aurel Joliat). Joliat went on to become popular with the Montreal fans and this aggravated Newsy so much that the first game he played against the Habs he tried to break his stick across Aurel's face.

Blake: A very good player, but how much of his reputation is based on his coaching skills - which far exceeded his skills as a player?

Durnan: On the basis of play alone Bill should be there. However his short career leaves him open to criticism as a selection.

Joliat: Another good, but not great player.

Vezina: Should be up there.

Lapointe/Shutt/Lemaire: A victim of their teammates. Lafleur, Cournoyer, Henri Richard, Serge Savard, Robinson, Gainey and Dryden all come from this era. Another three?

Frank Mahovlich: Didn't play long enough with us to warrant consideration.

Jacques Laperriere: Could be on the list, but he played through that deep time where the Canadiens have a lot of retired numbers. Also probably falls into the good, not great category.

Deidre Pitre: Probably could. He played a long time ago though...

thom 11-26-2013 03:13 PM

You know it took Bernie geoffrian over 40 yrs to have number retired and bouchard almost 60 yrs.We need to be careful who we retire.George Gillette was a good owner and so is Molson but they seem to be retiring too manynumbers maybe itstoo make more money i dont know but its time to stop for now.It will be emotional yrs down the road If Jacques Lemaire number is retired and Guy Lafleur is there to shake his hand and give him a hug.Dont know if it will happen but it would be a good story

BJG 11-26-2013 03:30 PM

Good list. How about Jack Laviolette?

Bon Esprit 11-26-2013 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by idk (Post 75063619)
The minimum requirement to have your number retired by the Canadiens should be to have your name in the Hall of Fame. That disqualifies J.C. Tremblay, Koivu (I don't foresee him making the HHoF), Little M, Ferguson, Carbonneau and Boucher. As for the others:

Lalonde: A very good player, but left the team under bad circumstances. Fought with his coach and with the owners and was unceremoniously dumped for nothing (an unknown prospect at the time named Aurel Joliat). Joliat went on to become popular with the Montreal fans and this aggravated Newsy so much that the first game he played against the Habs he tried to break his stick across Aurel's face.

Blake: A very good player, but how much of his reputation is based on his coaching skills - which far exceeded his skills as a player?

Durnan: On the basis of play alone Bill should be there. However his short career leaves him open to criticism as a selection.

Joliat: Another good, but not great player.

Vezina: Should be up there.

Lapointe/Shutt/Lemaire: A victim of their teammates. Lafleur, Cournoyer, Henri Richard, Serge Savard, Robinson, Gainey and Dryden all come from this era. Another three?

Frank Mahovlich: Didn't play long enough with us to warrant consideration.

Jacques Laperriere: Could be on the list, but he played through that deep time where the Canadiens have a lot of retired numbers. Also probably falls into the good, not great category.

Deidre Pitre: Probably could. He played a long time ago though...

Very good posting.

AntonCH 11-26-2013 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pricef (Post 75063573)
How Vezina's number isn't yet retired is just baffling.

ding ding ding ding dingding ding
we have a winner
winner winner chicken dinner

unlike a previous poster. in actuality its:
1) Vezina
2) all the rest

Good enough to have the goaltending trophy named after him, not good enough for our rafters? seriously?

kingdok 11-26-2013 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thom (Post 75063991)
You know it took Bernie geoffrian over 40 yrs to have number retired and bouchard almost 60 yrs.We need to be careful who we retire.George Gillette was a good owner and so is Molson but they seem to be retiring too manynumbers maybe itstoo make more money i dont know but its time to stop for now.It will be emotional yrs down the road If Jacques Lemaire number is retired and Guy Lafleur is there to shake his hand and give him a hug.Dont know if it will happen but it would be a good story

I'm no way advocating the retirement of more jerseys. This list is just what it is. A list of the best of the rest.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BJG (Post 75064745)
Good list. How about Jack Laviolette?

Don't know how to rank him. Frankly, his numbers don't look that great. You'll say different era, which I agree, but then again, while he played for the Habs, it was in the NHA. He only played 1 season in the NHL.

BJG 11-26-2013 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TGV (Post 75065523)
Don't know how to rank him. Frankly, his numbers don't look that great. You'll say different era, which I agree, but then again, while he played for the Habs, it was in the NHA. He only played 1 season in the NHL.

From Wiki, FWIW: "Laviolette's true place in hockey history has less to do with his scoring prowess and more to do with his role as the true founding organizer of the Canadiens hockey club. He was their first player, coach and general manager in their inaugural 1910 season".

SouthernHab 11-26-2013 11:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AntonCH (Post 75065509)
ding ding ding ding dingding ding
we have a winner
winner winner chicken dinner

unlike a previous poster. in actuality its:
1) Vezina
2) all the rest

Good enough to have the goaltending trophy named after him, not good enough for our rafters? seriously?

To play devils advocate, Vezina had a career NHL GAA of 3.28. Compare that with Dryden who had a career NHL GAA of 2.24.



In reality, Jacques Plante has the # 1 retired. Vezina wore the same number.

Sucks that Brian Hayward and Ron Tugnutt have no chance in hell at getting their # 1 retired either.:sarcasm:

TiCats 11-26-2013 11:31 PM

There are numbers retired twice, more than once.

Alexdaman 11-26-2013 11:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seb (Post 75058617)
1) Saku

2) The rest

meh, decent center, fought cancer... not sure of this one

AntonCH 11-26-2013 11:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TiCats (Post 75086129)
There are numbers retired twice, more than once.

say that 5 times fast

pine* 11-26-2013 11:44 PM

Saku.

/thread


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:31 PM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.