HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   Winnipeg Jets (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=29)
-   -   Thrashers AHL prospects season review (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=384117)

HF Article 05-28-2007 06:35 PM

Thrashers AHL prospects season review
 
The 2006-07 Chicago Wolves had several talented rookies including Brett Sterling, Nathan Oystrick, and Jordan LaVallee.

Read full article...





http://www.stubhub.com/promotions/sc...NHL_468x60.gif

wfan 05-30-2007 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HF Article (Post 9394051)
The 2006-07 Chicago Wolves had several talented rookies including Brett Sterling, Nathan Oystrick, and Jordan LaVallee.

Read full article...





http://www.stubhub.com/promotions/sc...NHL_468x60.gif

this article is sad. i don't know how one person (HOLLY GUNNING, which happened to be a woman!:sarcasm:) can judge players from Russia, Sweden, Czech rep. Slovakia, Finland and the AHL ... one i know for sure-she definately doesn't go all over the world to watch the games. i'm a wolves fan (as well as my Rangers), and actually asked the players on the team about miss Gunning. they said -quote from one unnamed forward on the team - "she has no idea what she is talking about, i'm not being mean, because she actualy allways says nice things about me (laugh) but her articles make us (the players on the squad) laugh"
they also said that the most famous sentence from her articles was from this years training camp (i think it was a rookie camp) when she said -" Little is not ready to make the team, he can't pass to himself of the boards" (they said it was one of the warm-up drills) :shakehead
they also mentioned that it was funny to see her at the practise this year and then reading what she had to say. i was told she has seen the guys 3 !!! times on the ice ALL YEAR LONG and made an article about it. they found it hilarious, so do i, now that i think about it....
just wanted to share my opinion. no need to get upset anybody

and believe me, i'm in no way making this up!!!!

Majik1987 05-30-2007 09:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wfan (Post 9411555)
(EDITTED :sarcasm:)

Little sarcasm icon or not, that was completely uncalled for. I was going to comment more on the rest, but this statement alone means you have absolutely no clue. You have completely discredited yourself.

Magnus Fulgur 05-30-2007 10:18 PM

I remember the comment picking apart the fact that he didn't pass well to himself off the boards, and I just shook my head at that one. When it comes to camp, I only care about three things with a player:
1.) Do they listen?
2.) Do they learn?
3.) Do they hustle?

Still, HG brings far more to the boards than anyone despite her faults (and we all have faults).

thedjpd 05-31-2007 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wfan (Post 9411555)
this article is sad. i don't know how one person (HOLLY GUNNING, which happened to be a woman!:sarcasm:) can judge players from Russia, Sweden, Czech rep. Slovakia, Finland and the AHL ... one i know for sure-she definately doesn't go all over the world to watch the games. i'm a wolves fan (as well as my Rangers), and actually asked the players on the team about miss Gunning. they said -quote from one unnamed forward on the team - "she has no idea what she is talking about, i'm not being mean, because she actualy allways says nice things about me (laugh) but her articles make us (the players on the squad) laugh"
they also said that the most famous sentence from her articles was from this years training camp (i think it was a rookie camp) when she said -" Little is not ready to make the team, he can't pass to himself of the boards" (they said it was one of the warm-up drills) :shakehead
they also mentioned that it was funny to see her at the practise this year and then reading what she had to say. i was told she has seen the guys 3 !!! times on the ice ALL YEAR LONG and made an article about it. they found it hilarious, so do i, now that i think about it....
just wanted to share my opinion. no need to get upset anybody

and believe me, i'm in no way making this up!!!!

You're more than welcome to keep your opinions to yourself. Personally, I enjoy Holly's articles.

Besides, my brother's uncle who has a friend who's one of your friends - who shall remain unnamed - says that you have no idea what you're talking about, and that you're an idiot. That is a direct quote.

See? I can do it too. Don't assume you bring any credibility with statements like the one you just made.

How could you honestly expect a post like that to not create any hostile reactions? You can't really be that much of a fool, can you?

DungeonK 05-31-2007 05:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wfan (Post 9411555)
this article is sad. i don't know how one person (HOLLY GUNNING, which happened to be a woman!:sarcasm:) can judge players from Russia, Sweden, Czech rep. Slovakia, Finland and the AHL ... one i know for sure-she definately doesn't go all over the world to watch the games. i'm a wolves fan (as well as my Rangers), and actually asked the players on the team about miss Gunning. they said -quote from one unnamed forward on the team - "she has no idea what she is talking about, i'm not being mean, because she actualy allways says nice things about me (laugh) but her articles make us (the players on the squad) laugh"
they also said that the most famous sentence from her articles was from this years training camp (i think it was a rookie camp) when she said -" Little is not ready to make the team, he can't pass to himself of the boards" (they said it was one of the warm-up drills) :shakehead
they also mentioned that it was funny to see her at the practise this year and then reading what she had to say. i was told she has seen the guys 3 !!! times on the ice ALL YEAR LONG and made an article about it. they found it hilarious, so do i, now that i think about it....
just wanted to share my opinion. no need to get upset anybody

and believe me, i'm in no way making this up!!!!

That was really mean... She obviously can't do the job of an entire scouting department, but in the absence of dependable sources of information on Thrashers prospects, getting to hear ANYTHING from someone consistently is enough to make me appreciate her and her work. If you don't like what she has to say, don't read it, but there is no need to flame her and her career. You also destroyed any validity I might have given you by showing you are sexist, which I have to assume is the source of your obvious jealousy and contempt towards Ms. Gunning.

Enstrom39 05-31-2007 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wfan (Post 9411555)
this article is sad. i don't know how one person (HOLLY GUNNING, which happened to be a woman!:sarcasm:) can judge players from Russia, Sweden, Czech rep. Slovakia, Finland and the AHL ... one i know for sure-she definately doesn't go all over the world to watch the games. i'm a wolves fan (as well as my Rangers), and actually asked the players on the team about miss Gunning. they said -quote from one unnamed forward on the team - "she has no idea what she is talking about, i'm not being mean, because she actualy allways says nice things about me (laugh) but her articles make us (the players on the squad) laugh"
they also said that the most famous sentence from her articles was from this years training camp (i think it was a rookie camp) when she said -" Little is not ready to make the team, he can't pass to himself of the boards" (they said it was one of the warm-up drills) :shakehead
they also mentioned that it was funny to see her at the practise this year and then reading what she had to say. i was told she has seen the guys 3 !!! times on the ice ALL YEAR LONG and made an article about it. they found it hilarious, so do i, now that i think about it....
just wanted to share my opinion. no need to get upset anybody and believe me, i'm in no way making this up!!!!

This is a discussion forum which means you're free to air your views of course. But instead of just attacking the writer why don't you offer your own take on the players? Making a long winded post pointing out that she's a woman and doesn't travel the world tells me nothing about why you think she is wrong. Attacking the writer does nothing for readers here. If have a specific disagreement state your case.

Having read her stuff for a long time I can tell you she has been right about a great many players in the long run. I can also tell you that sometimes players have inflated opinions about themselves or certain teammates. They're not always right either. I've heard some hilarious things over the years about how player X is certain to make it to the NHL when it is pretty obvious to me that player X needs a miracle for that to happen. Brad Tapper is one person who comes to mind.

btn 06-01-2007 07:04 AM

Holly Gunning is a woman?

Learn something new every day :sarcasm:

I think her track record speaks for itself, and you won't find anyone with a better working knowledge of the Thrashers organization around these parts. If it isn't her opinion, it is likely the opinion of one of the main decision makers in Thrashers management.

Tekneek 06-01-2007 08:50 AM

Wow, hockey players might laugh about what somebody writes about them? They might not agree with it? Remind me why this should be news to anyone?

If you think you've got a better take, please write it. If these players think they have a better idea, they should take up the keyboard and communicate it. They aren't under any NDA that would prevent them from having a blog, posting on messageboards, or other things. I know they have the time to do a little bit.

If one of you "smart" and "insightful" hockey players is reading this, please accept the challenge and give an official retort to Holly's articles instead of sniping behind her back.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:55 PM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.