HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   NHL Draft - Prospects (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Who is better (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=42689)

not quite yoda 01-10-2004 01:23 PM

Who is better
 
Which of these two prospects/young players (drafted the same year, same round) are better NHLers or potential NHLers so far?

I realize that some play different positions, but if you could still evaluate their value.

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Jamie 01-10-2004 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by espion
Which of these two prospects/young players (drafted the same year, same round) are better NHLers or potential NHLers so far?

I realize that some play different positions, but if you could still evaluate their value.

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Well, I'll take my best shot at it...

1)Vaananen
2)Don't know overly much about Higgins, so going by reports and picking him
3)Wowyitka
4)O'Sullivan
5)Komisarek(tough one though)
6)Parise(Kastistyin could definetly be better, but is risky)

Of course, we won't really know the right answers for about 5 years or so, but this is my guess.

moosefan 01-10-2004 01:27 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen? Ribeiro (just don't like Vaananen)

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov? Higgins

Woywitka or Perezhogin? Perezhogin

O`Sullivan or Urquhart? O'Sullivan

Komisarek or Hamhuis? Komisarek

Parisť or Kastsitsyn? Parise (though I really like Kastsitsyn)

L3DZ3P 01-10-2004 01:32 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen?Ribeiro

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?Higgins

Woywitka or Perezhogin?Perezhogin

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?O`Sullivan

Komisarek or Hamhuis?Hamhuis

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?Kastsitsyn

leafaholix* 01-10-2004 01:37 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov
Woywitka or Perezhogin
O'Sullivan or Urquhart
Komisarek or Hamhuis
Parisť or Kastsitsyn

Maithz 01-10-2004 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by go pierre hedin
Ribeiro or Vaananen
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov
Woywitka or Perezhogin
O'Sullivan or Urquhart
Komisarek or Hamhuis
Parisť or Kastsitsyn


Just say that the best are all none habs prospect . :joker:

leafaholix* 01-10-2004 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HABS-65
Just say that the best are all none habs prospect . :joker:

Or... that's just what I honestly feel.

Howard35 01-10-2004 02:19 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Winston Wolf 01-10-2004 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by go pierre hedin
Ribeiro or Vaananen
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov
Woywitka or Perezhogin
O'Sullivan or Urquhart
Komisarek or Hamhuis
Parisť or Kastsitsyn

Same for me.

Teemu 01-10-2004 02:46 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen?
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?
Woywitka or Perezhogin?
O`Sullivan or Urquhart?
Komisarek or Hamhuis?
Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Grizzly Adams 01-10-2004 02:51 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart? No Opinion

Komisarek or Hamhuis? Even

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

PEli* 01-10-2004 03:03 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov

Woywitka or Perezhogin

O`Sullivan or Urquhart - Can't decide. Haven't seen O'Sullivan play much.

Komisarek or Hamhuis

Parisť or Kastsitsyn - Very tough.

#37-#93-#27* 01-10-2004 03:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by espion
Which of these two prospects/young players (drafted the same year, same round) are better NHLers or potential NHLers so far?

I realize that some play different positions, but if you could still evaluate their value.

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Vaananen easily
Grebeshkov easily
Woywitka close
not sure
tough call, I'll pick Komisaurus
another toughy, but I'll go with Parise

Jeffrey 01-10-2004 03:09 PM

the only guy habs property that i fell better than the other is Woywitka with Perezhogin (perezhogin is just getting an awesome 2nd part of the year with Hamilton )
parise/kastitsyn and Grebeshov/Higgins are pretty even ...
but hamhuis is better than komi
and O'sullivan is better than urquhart
ribeiro need to learn consistency before i put him over vaananen

Kev88 01-10-2004 03:13 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen? (100% sure)
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov? (By far)
Woywitka or Perezhogin? (By far)
O`Sullivan or Urquhart?
Komisarek or Hamhuis? (Really close)
Parisť or Kastsitsyn?[/QUOTE](Extremely close)

Alex Kovalev 01-10-2004 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by espion
Which of these two prospects/young players (drafted the same year, same round) are better NHLers or potential NHLers so far?

I realize that some play different positions, but if you could still evaluate their value.

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Vaananen

Grebeshkov

Perezhogin

O'Sullivan

Hamhuis

Parisť

FlyersGuy69 01-10-2004 03:28 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

canucksfan 01-10-2004 04:06 PM

Vaananen
Higgins
Woywitka
O'Sullivan
Hamhuis
Parise

Fedz 01-10-2004 04:25 PM

Ribeiro or Vaananen
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov
Woywitka or Perezhogin
O'Sullivan or Urquhart
Komisarek or Hamhuis
Parisť or Kastsitsyn


guess thats the same as a few ppls.

Jeffrey 01-10-2004 04:34 PM

I just can't see woywitka over perezhogin even if I really like woywitka ...
anyway this is just my opionion :o

Dr_Chimera* 01-10-2004 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kryoptix
I just can't see woywitka over perezhogin even if I really like woywitka ...
anyway this is just my opionion :o

Perezhogin doesn't deserve to be ahead of many good prospects right now, including Woywitka.

He's been very slow to adjust to North American play, he's a fairly plain player, not terribly creative, and doesn't work hard enough.

I interviewed him once, and he's a bit of a weird kid - kind of laid back and he plays laid back too. I don't think he'll be a great player.

Jeffrey 01-10-2004 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr_Chimera
Perezhogin doesn't deserve to be ahead of many good prospects right now, including Woywitka.

He's been very slow to adjust to North American play, he's a fairly plain player, not terribly creative, and doesn't work hard enough.

I interviewed him once, and he's a bit of a weird kid - kind of laid back and he plays laid back too. I don't think he'll be a great player.

I've heard that his main strenght was is work ethic and his defensive play .. i dunno but i think he could be a nice 3rd line player ...
woywitka is also a good prospect very strong and good defensively but he don't show more creativity than perezhogin .. both are real good prospect IMO but i'll give the edge to perezhogin because of his speed and his famous wrist shot ;)

Pinto 01-10-2004 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by espion
Which of these two prospects/young players (drafted the same year, same round) are better NHLers or potential NHLers so far?

I realize that some play different positions, but if you could still evaluate their value.

Ribeiro or Vaananen?

C. Higgins or Grebeshkov?

Woywitka or Perezhogin?

O`Sullivan or Urquhart?

Komisarek or Hamhuis?

Parisť or Kastsitsyn?

Vaananen
Grebeshkov
Perezhogin
O'Sullivan
Komi
Parise

willie 01-10-2004 05:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hokay
Ribeiro or Vaananen? (100% sure)
C. Higgins or Grebeshkov? (By far)
Woywitka or Perezhogin? (By far)

"BY FAR"??? :lol: Please.

Dr_Chimera* 01-10-2004 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kryoptix
I've heard that his main strenght was is work ethic and his defensive play .. i dunno but i think he could be a nice 3rd line player ...
woywitka is also a good prospect very strong and good defensively but he don't show more creativity than perezhogin .. both are real good prospect IMO but i'll give the edge to perezhogin because of his speed and his famous wrist shot ;)

Well, he's (perezhogin) a responsible all-around player - I think people are confusing being responsible for being hard-working. He doesn't show nearly enough hustle for my liking.

Woywitka is a safer player - nothing fancy, but he's much more solid and poised. It's not Woywitka's job to be terribly offensively creative. He's mostly a defensive guy and he does his job well.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:59 PM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.