HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   Ottawa Senators (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   The game is a foot (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=67825)

rebedom 04-04-2004 03:59 PM

The game is a foot
 
Let's see how these two teams match up and who is the better team. We rank them by points, positions and all other intangibles.

Left Wing

Bondra - 50 points Roberts - 48 points (even)
Schafer - 39 points Tucker - 32 points (even)
Vermette - 14 points Renberg - 25 points (Renberg)
Varada - 10 points Reichel - 30 points (Reichel)
Langfeld - 17 points Kilger - 2 points (Langfeld)

Right Wing

Hossa - 82 points Nolan - 48 points (Hossa)
Alfredson - 80 points Mogilny - 30 points (Alfredson)
Havlat - 68 points Fitzgerald - 17 points (Havlat)
Neil - 16 points Domi - 20 points (Domi - barely)

Centre

Spezza - 55 points Sudin - 75 points (Sundin)
Smolinski - 46 points Nieuwendyk - 50 points (even)
Bonk - 43 points Francis - 40 points (even)
White - 29 points Andropov - 31 points (even)
Fisher - 10 points Stajan - 27 points (even - intangibles)
(Fisher 24 games - Stajan 69 games)
Van Allan - 12 points Ponikarovsky - 27 points (Ponikarovsky)

Defence

Redden - 43 McCabe - 53 points (McCabe)
Chara - 41 Leetch - 51 points (even - intangibles)
Phillips - 23 Kaberle - 31 points (Phillips - intangibles)
de Vries - 16 Klee - 29 points (Klee)
Pothier - 8 Berehowskey - 20 points (Berehowsky)
Simpson - 8 Pilar - 19 points (Pilar)
Leshyshyn - 5 Johanson - 6 points (even)
Volchenkov- 3 Marchment - 4 points (even)

Wow, closer than I thought and it looks like the edge goes to the stinking Leafs. People have been talking in Ottawa all year about Redden and Chara having Norris Trophy years but McCabe looks to me like he may win it. Adding Leetch and Klee has improved their defence ten fold.

BlueAndWhite 04-04-2004 04:08 PM

First off, McCabe has an OUTSIDE shot at being nominated for the Norris. He doesn't have a chance at winning the thing.

Secondly, unlike some belligerent fans on both sides, I do think this will be a hard, fought and close series. The two teams are evenly matched.

Third, I notice that your comparisons had selective qualifiers/disclaimers. You made some obvious mistakes on the Senators side, but more so on the Leafs side as well.:amazed:

i.e. you noted the discrepancy between Fisher and Stajan in terms of GP (in favour of Fisher) but left out the fact that Johansson (6 pts) has played only 8 games while Leschyshyn (5 pts) has played in 56 games.

Sting 04-04-2004 04:11 PM

Weird way of ranking them sometimes because Varada has a load less games played than Reichel...and I think anyone would take him over Reichel.

I'll also take Pothier over Berehowsky any day, and Volchenkov over Marchment..but oh well.

We seem to have a better D-Core and our wingers are substantially better...they've got the advantage as far as centres go tho. Maybe we'll get to see 1st line Bonk come out of his shell??

The Big P 04-04-2004 04:11 PM

Not to mention that for some reason Berehowsky is now better than Pothier?

Steve L* 04-04-2004 04:12 PM

Thats all well and good but you left out the most important position, the Goalie.
I hate to say it but:
Belfour >>> Lalime or Prusek.

Spezza 04-04-2004 04:22 PM

Yeah but McCabe has got that flying ass check that winds me up something else.

I don't really believe in these type of comparisons. The key to this series is Ottawa's game plan over the series.

Bondra was brought into shore up the 2nd unit of the PP and if you believe the rumour mill, we shouldn't expect to see him on Thursday night. The Leafs PK has our #1 PP unit and it's scheme well scouted. They've been ineffective. Bondra running that #2 PP unit certainly would have given us a different weapon.

There is also faceoff matchups - I think this is where Toronto has the most significant edge over us. Francis and Niewendyk are just brilliant in the circle. A couple of signs of improvement tho: Havlats GWG straight off the faceoff play against the panthers and White was great in the faceoff circle yesterday. We've got a number of guys who can play center and take faceoffs - lets use them and try and make sure that we've got our lefties and righties taking faceoffs on the correct side in the defensive zone.

Augustus 04-04-2004 06:31 PM

Impossible to use stats or numbers to compare these teams. One stat stands out and that calls for a very close match - Leafs 103 points, Sens 102. No statistical significance in these kinds of numbers. Leafs have not had a great home record and Sens have not had a great road record. I'm not prepared to say that the home ice advantage is crucial, though it is more important than stats. History is also not relevant because regular season dominance has not carried over into playoffs before. Both coaches have their weaknesses and strengths.

Winner will be determined by effort, ability to avoid bad penalties, the power play, the goaltending, and injuries.

Of course I am pulling for a Leaf win, as you guys are for a Sens win.

May the better team over a short series live long, prosper and go all the way.

:handclap: :handclap:

gmdevils 04-04-2004 06:43 PM

Sorry for interrupting... but I had to say something

afoot is one word

Kemosabe 04-05-2004 06:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmdevils
Sorry for interrupting... but I had to say something

afoot is one word


THANK YOU!! I came to this thread just to say that but then started reading and forgot. A little editing can go a long way. :handclap:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:53 PM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.