HFBoards

HFBoards (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/index.php)
-   New York Rangers (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   Rangers comparison game (http://hfboards.hockeysfuture.com/showthread.php?t=977803)

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 02:40 PM

Rangers comparison game
 
the rules...any prospect that is rangers property signed or unsigned must have 2 years or less at nhl level....current players only....

Dylan McIlrath....Brooks Orpik
Tim Erixon....... Niklas Hjalmarsson
Michael Sauer....Bryce Salvador
Micheal Del Zotto.....JM Liles
Carl Hagelin......Mason Raymond
Jason Wilson.....Chris Neil
Oscar Lindberg......Samuel Pahlsson
Shane McColgan....Brad Marchand
Pavel Valentenko......Christian Schubert...
Samuel Noreau...Andy Sutton
JT Miller...Dustin Brown
Please feel free to add prospects and make your own comparisons

NYR Viper 09-01-2011 02:48 PM

Dylan McIlrath - Douglas Murray
JT Miller - Ryan Kesler
Ryan Bourque - Darren Helm
Chris Kreider - Erik Cole
Tomas Kundratek - Brad Stuart
Christian Thomas - Mike Cammeleri
Samuel Noreau - Matt Carkner
Carl Hagelin - Lauri Korpikoski
Jesper Fasth - Loui Eriksson
Oscar Lindberg - Manny Malhotra

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NYR Boyler87 (Post 36371435)
Dylan McIlrath - Douglas Murray
JT Miller - Keith Tkachuk
Ryan Bourque - Darren Helm
Chris Kreider - Erik Cole
Tomas Kundratek - Brad Stuart
Christian Thomas - Mike Cammeleri
Samuel Noreau - Matt Carkner
Carl Hagelin - Kris Draper
Jesper Fasth - Loui Eriksson
Oscar Lindberg - Manny Malhotra

Current players only....good list though...Douglas Murray is underrated ...ufa next year I believe..

JeffMangum 09-01-2011 02:52 PM

Dylan McIlrath...Robyn Regehr
Tim Erixon....... Fedor Tyutin
Michael Sauer....Chris Phillips
Micheal Del Zotto.....Tomas Kaberle with an edge
Carl Hagelin......Ruslan Fedotenko
Jason Wilson.....Dane Byers
Oscar Lindberg......Samuel Pahlsson
Shane McColgan....Stefan Della Rovere
Pavel Valentenko......Garnet Exelby
Samuel Noreau...No clue
JT Miller...Ryan Callahan

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian Boyle (Post 36371543)
Dylan McIlrath...Robyn Regehr
Tim Erixon....... Fedor Tyutin
Michael Sauer....Chris Phillips
Micheal Del Zotto.....Tomas Kaberle with an edge
Carl Hagelin......Ruslan Fedotenko
Jason Wilson.....Dane Byers
Oscar Lindberg......Samuel Pahlsson
Shane McColgan....Stefan Della Rovere
Pavel Valentenko......Garnet Exelby
Samuel Noreau...No clue
JT Miller...Ryan Callahan


Please be wrong about Valentenko and McColgan comparisons...exelby sucks...

NYR Viper 09-01-2011 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punxrocknyc19 (Post 36371507)
Current players only....good list though...Douglas Murray is underrated ...ufa next year I believe..

Changed it to current players. Yeah, people don't realize how good of a player Douglas Murray is. He is a stalwart on SJ's defense and an absolute monster on their back-end.

I think Jovanovski, Orpik, Murray, Chara, Regehr are all good comparables for McIlrath.

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 03:04 PM

Mats Zuccarello.....Sergei Samsonov......


I doubt Zuccarello will be like St.Louis like most think he will be.......

NYR Viper 09-01-2011 03:11 PM

A few more:

Shane McColgan - Ryan Callahan
Michal St. Croix - Eric Christensen
Pavel Valentenko - Anton Volchenkov/Jason Strudwick (Mix)
Jason Wilson - Brandon Prust
Randy McNaught - George Parros

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NYR Boyler87 (Post 36372053)
A few more:

Shane McColgan - Ryan Callahan
Michal St. Croix - Eric Christensen
Pavel Valentenko - Anton Volchenkov/Jason Strudwick (Mix)
Jason Wilson - Brandon Prust
Randy McNaught - George Parros

I really hope that christensen comparison is wrong....

Propane Nightmares 09-01-2011 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punxrocknyc19 (Post 36371617)
Please be wrong about Valentenko and McColgan comparisons...exelby sucks...

I think the comparisons are meant to be about the style of play, not projected talent

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 03:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshy3413 (Post 36372521)
I think the comparisons are meant to be about the style of play, not projected talent

Exelby and Valentenko are different type of players... I can't recall Valentenko fighting like Exelby does....

Alphacat 09-01-2011 04:17 PM

Dylan McIlrath...Matt Green
Carl Hagelin...John Madden
Shane McColgan...Brad Marchand
J.T. Miller...Kesler (lite)
Jesper Fasth...Loui Eriksson
Michael St. Croix...Mason Raymond
Chris Kreider...Erik Cole
Ryan Bourque...Cally (lite)
Tim Erixon...Brian Rafalski (i know he retired, but pretty current)

Clowes Line 09-01-2011 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punxrocknyc19 (Post 36371257)
the rules...any prospect that is rangers property signed or unsigned must have 2 years or less at nhl level....current players only....

Dylan McIlrath....Brooks Orpik
Tim Erixon....... Niklas Hjalmarsson
Michael Sauer....Bryce Salvador
Micheal Del Zotto.....JM Liles
Carl Hagelin......Mason Raymond
Jason Wilson.....Chris Neil
Oscar Lindberg......Samuel Pahlsson
Shane McColgan....Brad Marchand
Pavel Valentenko......Christian Schubert...
Samuel Noreau...Andy Sutton
JT Miller...Dustin Brown
Please feel free to add prospects and make your own comparisons

Deleted a few prospects and replaced them with some others.

Dylan McIlrath - Chris Pronger, less offensive upside
Tim Erixon - Marc Staal with Streit offensive upside
Michael Sauer - Brooks Orpik
Chris Kreider - Ryan Kesler
Carl Hagelin - Samuel Pahlson
Shane McColgan - Ryan Callahan/Brad Marchand
JT Miller - Dustin Brown
Michael Del Zotto - I think Liles is a good comparison
Ryan McDonagh - Ryan McDonagh, this kid is gonna make a name for himself.

Artem Anisimov 09-01-2011 04:32 PM

Dylan McIlrath...Mattias Ohlund
Carl Hagelin...Darren Helm
Shane McColgan...Brad Marchand
J.T. Miller...R.J. Umberger
Jesper Fasth...Henrik Zetterberg
Michael St. Croix...Rich Peverley
Chris Krieder...Johan Franzen
Ryan Bourgue...Drew Miller
Tim Erixon...Christian Ehrhoff
Oscar Lindberg...Chris Kelly

Propane Nightmares 09-01-2011 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punxrocknyc19 (Post 36372821)
Exelby and Valentenko are different type of players... I can't recall Valentenko fighting like Exelby does....

Well they're both big hitters, I think that's why that comparison was made

New York RKY 09-01-2011 04:52 PM

Dylan McIlrath - Douglas Murray (with maybe a little more offensive potential)
JT Miller - Dustin Brown
Tim Erixon - A cross between Marc Staal and possibly Kevin Shattenkirk offensive potential
Ryan Bourque - Drew Miller
Chris Kreider - Milan Lucic with Erik Cole speed
Tomas Kundratek - no clue
Christian Thomas - Mike Cammalleri, Brian Gionta
Samuel Noreau - no idea
Carl Hagelin - Alex Burrows-lite
Jesper Fasth - Loui Eriksson-feather lite
Oscar Lindberg - Manny Malhotra, John Madden, Dave Bolland build

eco's bones 09-01-2011 05:03 PM

Just to go outside the rules of the game here--rules are meant to be broken anyway but the guy McIlrath projects out to be is Jeff Beukeboom--both 6'5 mean stay at home defensemen. McIlrath may be a little bit better skater and a better fighter but it's about the same offense, size and orneriness. Both very good open ice hitters as well. McIlrath will have to play with more discipline than Beukeboom just because of the way the game has changed from when Beukeboom played for us.

I don't think the comparison to Orpik is that good because Orpik's not really a fighter per se--McIlrath has a bit of a goon factor and is somewhat likely to be considered a top NHL heavyweight some day. A lot else about Orpik compares though. Murray as well is only an occasional fighter.

Punxrocknyc19* 09-01-2011 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by New York RKY (Post 36374569)
Dylan McIlrath - Douglas Murray (with maybe a little more offensive potential)
JT Miller - Dustin Brown
Tim Erixon - A cross between Marc Staal and possibly Kevin Shattenkirk offensive potential
Ryan Bourque - Drew Miller
Chris Kreider - Milan Lucic with Erik Cole speed
Tomas Kundratek - no clue
Christian Thomas - Mike Cammalleri, Brian Gionta
Samuel Noreau - no idea
Carl Hagelin - Alex Burrows-lite
Jesper Fasth - Loui Eriksson-feather lite
Oscar Lindberg - Manny Malhotra, John Madden, Dave Bolland build

is Kreider nasty or physical??? Erik Cole is a great comparison that i have read....id love a future Lucic on this team...is Hagelin as gritty or nasty as Burrows?? i think Hagelin will be a Mason Raymond, TJ Oshie type player..

New York RKY 09-01-2011 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punxrocknyc19 (Post 36375149)
is Kreider nasty or physical??? Erik Cole is a great comparison that i have read....id love a future Lucic on this team...is Hagelin as gritty or nasty as Burrows?? i think Hagelin will be a Mason Raymond, TJ Oshie type player..

Kreider might not have the fighting snarl like Lucic, but I like how both use their bodies to protect the puck and do work down low.

I guess Raymond would be a better comparison for Hagelin, but I also think he might be more offensively talented then Raymond, hence why I said in the mold of a Burrows type player.

gotmonte 09-01-2011 08:38 PM

some good comparisons. If half our prospects turn into half the people put in here, we have a DYNASTY FOR ATLEAST 10-12 YEARS HERE!!!! :handclap: :yo:

McSauer 09-01-2011 08:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HagelinForPresident (Post 36374073)
Ryan McDonagh - Ryan McDonagh, this kid is gonna make a name for himself.

Exactly, awesome.

Swedish Fish 09-01-2011 09:01 PM

I would post my list but its pretty much covered already :yo:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:24 AM.

vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HFBoards.com, A property of CraveOnline, a division of AtomicOnline LLC ©2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.