View Single Post
Old
08-05-2007, 10:12 PM
  #1
Hockey Outsider
Registered User
 
Hockey Outsider's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Country: Canada
Posts: 3,429
vCash: 500
Third-Team All Stars (1965-present)

I’ve assembled the “third-team” all-stars for each year from 1965 to the present, based on actual NHL voting records. My sources include the Globe & Mail, the Toronto Star, and the Awards Voting thread on this website. The source for voting from 1965-1978 is the Globe, unless otherwise stated, and the source from 1979-present is HFBoards, unless otherwise stated.

The purpose of this exercise was to 1) highlight excellent players who have been overlooked due to tough competition at their position, 2) look for trends/patterns in the voting and 3) kill time while fighting a cold that just won’t go away. I think I’ve been successful on all three counts.

Since this is based entirely on the actual voting results, it's as official and authoritative as the first- and second-team all-star selections (though I am missing data).

I looked into 1960-1964, but voting results aren’t available.

1965
C: Henri Richard
LW: Johnny Bucyk
RW: Rod Gilbert
D: Marcel Pronovost, Harry Howell
G: Johnny Bower

1966
C: Norm Ullman
LW: Doug Mohns
RW: Bob Nevin
D: JC Tremblay, Harry Howell
G: Roger Crozier

1967
(*From the Toronto Star; data missing)
RW: Rod Gilbert

1968
C: Jean Beliveau
LW: Gilles Tremblay
RW: John McKenzie
D: Pierre Pilote, Ted Green
G: Johnny Bower

1969
(*From the Toronto Star)
C: Red Berenson
LW: Vic Hadfield
RW: Ken Hodge
D: Al Arbour, Jim Neilson
G: Jacques Plante

1970
C: Walt Tkaczuk
LW: Johnny Bucyk
RW: Bill Goldsworthy
D: Al Arbour, Jim Neilson
G: Jacques Plante

1971
C: Norm Ullman
LW: Wayne Cashman
RW: John McKenzie
D: Keith Magnuson, Dallas Smith
G: Tony Esposito

1972
C: Bobby Clarke
LW: Frank Mahovlich
RW: Mickey Redmond
D: J.C. Tremblay, Dallas Smith
G: Gerry Cheevers

1973
C: Gil Perreault
LW: Johnny Bucyk
RW: Jim Pappin
D: Jacques Laperriere, Serge Savard
G: Gilles Villemure

1974
C: Darryl Sittler
LW: Frank Mahovlich
RW: Bill Goldsworthy
D: Guy Lapointe, Carol Vadnais
G: Gilles Gilbert

1975 (* From HFBoards)
C: Gil Perreault
LW: Danny Grant
RW: Rod Gilbert
D: Brad Park, Serge Savard
G: Gary Smith

1976
C: Pete Mahovlich
LW: Chuck Lafley
RW: Jean Pronovost
D: Serge Savard, Jimmy Watson
G: Wayne Stephenson

1977 (* From HFBoards)
C: Bobby Clarke
LW: Eric Vail
RW: Marcel Dionne*
D: Serge Savard, Brad Park
G: Glen Resch

* Marcel Dionne was a centre this year and was named as the first-team all-star centre. Still, he received the 3rd-most votes as a RW. The actually right-winger with the most votes was the second-best #99 in history, Wilf Paiment.

1978
C: Bobby Clarke
LW: Bill Barber
RW: Terry O'Reilly
D: Serge Savard, Barry Beck
G: Tony Esposito

* Finally found a source for this. Link.

1979
(*Using data from HFBoards post from now on)
C: Guy Chouinard
LW: Steve Shutt
RW: Bob MacMillan
D: Barry Beck, Guy Lapointe
G: Mike Palmateer

1980
C: Gil Perreault
LW: Steve Payne
RW: Mike Bossy
D: Mark Howe, Barry Beck
G: Mike Liut

1981
C: Bryan Trottier
LW: Steve Shutt
RW: Wayne Babych
D: Rod Langway, Larry Murphy
G: Don Edwards

1982
C: Peter Stastny
LW: Bill Barber
RW: Dino Ciccarelli
D: Craig Hartsburg, Larry Robinson
G: Rick Wamsley

1983
C: Peter Stastny
LW: Al Secord
RW: Rick Middleton
D: Doug Wilson, Denis Potvin
G: Murray Bannerman

1984
C: Barry Pederson
LW: John Ogrodnick
RW: Rick Middleton
D: Phil Housley, Mike Ramsay
G: Rejean Lemelin

1985
C: Marcel Dionne
LW: Michel Goulet
RW: Tim Kerr
D: Scott Stevens, Mark Howe
G: Reggie Lemelin

1986
C: Peter Stastny
LW: Glenn Anderson
RW: Tim Kerr
D: Rod Langway, Doug Wilson
G: Grant Fuhr

1987
C: Dale Hawerchuk
LW: Esa Tikkanen
RW: Dino Ciccarelli
D: Larry Robinson, Ulf Samuelsson
G: Grant Fuhr

(This has to be the toughest all-star team to play against!)

1988
C: Denis Savard
LW: Mats Naslund
RW: Craig Simpson
D: Kevin Lowe, Chris Chelios
G: Tom Barrasso

1989
C: Steve Yzerman
LW: Mats Naslund
RW: Rob Brown
D: Steve Duchesne, Brad McCrimmon
G: Greg Millen

1990
C: Steve Yzerman
LW: Vincent Damphousse
RW: Stephane Richer
D: Phil Housley, Al Iafrate
G: Andy Moog

1991
C: Joe Sakic
LW: Pat Verbeek
RW: Theo Fleury
D: Paul Coffey, Scott Stevens
G: Andy Moog

1992
C: Wayne Gretzky
LW: Gary Roberts
RW: Joe Mullen
D: Larry Murphy, Al MacInnis
G: Ed Belfour

1993
C: Doug Gilmour
LW: Dave Andreychuk
RW: Pavel Bure
D: Kevin Hatcher, Phil Housley
G: Felix Potvin

1994
C: Doug Gilmour
LW: Dave Andreychuk
RW: Brett Hull
D: Sergei Zubov, Chris Chelios
G: Patrick Roy

1995
C: Ron Francis
LW: Brendan Shanahan
RW: Brett Hull
D: Eric Desjardins, Phil Housley
G: Jim Carey

* See write-up in awards results thread for description of unusual voting procedure for 1995.

1996
C: Mark Messier
LW: Keith Tkachuk
RW: Teemu Selanne
D: Paul Coffey, Nicklas Lidstrom
G: Martin Brodeur

1997
C: Peter Forsberg
LW: Keith Tkachuk
RW: Ziggy Palffy
D: Vladimir Konstantinov, Nicklas Lidstrom
G: Patrick Roy

1998
C: Ron Francis
LW: Rod Brind’Amour
RW: Pavel Bure
D: Scott Stevens, Ray Bourque
G: Ed Belfour

1999
C: Eric Lindros
LW: Pavol Demitra
RW: Theo Fleury
D: Chris Pronger, Larry Murphy
G: Ron Tugnutt

2000
C: Joe Sakic
LW: John LeClair
RW: Owen Nolan
D: Sergei Gonchar, Ray Bourque
G: Martin Brodeur

2001
C: Doug Weight
LW: Markus Naslund
RW: Alexei Kovalev
D: Brian Leetch, Sergei Gonchar
G: Martin Brodeur

2002
C: Ron Francis
LW: Todd Bertuzzi
RW: Glenn Murray
D: Chris Pronger, Teppo Numminen
G: Sean Burke

2003
C: Mike Modano
LW: Brendan Shanahan
RW: Marian Hossa
D: Rob Blake, Sergei Zubov
G: Ed Belfour

2004
C: Joe Thornton
LW: Patrik Elias
RW: Marian Hossa
D: Nicklas Lidstrom, Adrian Aucoin
G: Marty Turco

2006
C: Sidney Crosby
LW: Ilya Kovalchuk
RW: Jonathan Cheechoo
D: Chris Pronger, Wade Redden
G: Henrik Lundqvist

2007
C: Joe Thornton
LW: Daniel Sedin
RW: Marian Hossa
D: Kimmo Timmonen, Dion Phaneuf
G: Dominik Hasek

2008
C: Pavel Datsyuk
LW: Ilya Kovalchuk
RW: Daniel Alfredsson
D: Sergei Gonchar, Andrei Markov
G: J.S. Giguere

2009
C: Sidney Crosby
LW: Ilya Kovalchuk
RW: Martin St. Louis
D: Shea Weber, Andrei Markov
G: Roberto Luongo

2010
C: Steven Stamkos
LW: Patrick Marleau
RW: Marian Gaborik
D: Chris Pronger, Dan Boyle
G: Martin Brodeur


Last edited by Hockey Outsider: 07-02-2010 at 04:28 PM.
Hockey Outsider is offline   Reply With Quote