View Single Post
Old
08-06-2007, 12:56 PM
  #1
Garbs
Registered User
 
Garbs's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: London, Ontario
Country: Canada
Posts: 14,808
vCash: 500
LeBron James vs. Sidney Crosby

Who is the better player within their respective sports? Who will have achieved more by the time their careers are finished?

Who is the greater phenom?

LeBron James (3 years pro)

2003-2004 NBA First All-Rookie Team (19 years old)
2003-2004 NBA Rookie of the Year (19 years old)
2004-2005 Second All-NBA Team (20 years old)
2005-2006 First All-NBA Team (21 years old)
2006-2007 Second All-NBA Team (22 years old)
3 All-Star Appearences (Won MVP of the game in 2005-2006)

Cleveland Cavaliers

2004-2005 : 42 W - 40 L / 9th in conference
(Did not qualify for playoffs)
2005-2006 : 50 W - 32 L / 4th in conference
(Lost in Conference Semifinals)
2006-2007 : 50 W - 32 L / 2nd in conference
(Lost in Finals)

***

Sidney Crosby (2 years pro)

2005-2006 NHL All-Rookie Team (18 years old)
2006-2007 NHL First All-Star Team (19 years old)
2006-2007 NHL Art Ross Trophy (19 years old)
2006-2007 NHL Lester B. Person Award (19 years old)
2006-2007 NHL Hart Trophy (19 years old)
1 All-Star Appearence

Pittsburgh Penguins

2005-2006 : 22 W - 46 L - 14 OTL / 15th in conference
(Did not qualify for playoffs)
2006-2007 : 47 W - 24 L - 11 OTL / 5th in conference
(Lost in Conference Quarterfinals)

***

Personally I don't even think this is close, but I won't give my answer just yet.

Garbs is offline   Reply With Quote