View Single Post
Old
07-24-2008, 02:57 PM
  #21
Anod
Registered User
 
Anod's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Toronto, ON
Country: Canada
Posts: 766
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by SJSHARK View Post
Jay B. is a franchise player (probably in the top 5 best present and future defensemen in the NHL) and his value could be compared to the likes of Pronger, Phaneuf and Chara. Campbell is a one dimensional player- a great skating defenseman and PP quarterback- but thats it. J-Bo is worth much more because of his potential on both ends of the ice. Look what Pronger did for the Oilers and Ducks, just with his presence they went from playoff borderline to a cup contending teams. Jay B will have the same effect on an up-and-coming team and will fetch attention from half of the NHL.

Pronger trade return- 2 Firsts, 1 Second, 1 top (then) Prospect=Smid, and 2nd or 3rd line farward= Joffory Lupul. So basically 3 firsts 1 second and a seasoned player, which is still underpayment. Jay could fetch more because other teams are very aware what this kind of defenseman can do for their team.

If Martin cant sign him long term, then he has to trade him. Teams will overpay for him just like they do for free agents. I say pull the trigger.

There are big differences between Prongers situation and Bouwmeesters

1) Pronger had a LOT of Playoff experience, Bouwmeester has none
2) Pronger had 4 years left on a decent contract, when he was traded, Bouwmeester has 1 year of restricted free agency.
3) Pronger has a better all round game. His hitting is second to none, his defensive positioning is top notch and he can score points. Bouwmeester is still developing and he is a sound positional defenseman but his hitting is not ferocious and his scoring is not where everybody expected..

Anod is offline   Reply With Quote