View Single Post
Old
08-06-2004, 12:41 PM
  #6
dumpsathernow*
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 612
vCash: 500
Yeah I know that but I still think even a fan can look at production of a prospect and judge him somewhat fairly. No prospect for the most part is a lock. However, if Dawes is a 5.5 then we might as well release him.

I don't know why Wiseman would be a 4.5 He's a 2 way player who has put up 2 solid offensive years in a tough defensive league in the AHL and he's getting better.

Look at Pihlman on the Devils. The guy had 10 G, 19 A for a pathetic 29 points and is rated a 7.0. I don't care how bad your team is. You better put a lot more then 29 points up in the minors if you want to be rated the same as Fedor.

Wiseman on the other hand on a poor offensive team had stats the last 2 years

GM G A P
77 17 35 52
62 25 27 52

I just find it hard to believe because Pihlman is 6'3 it makes him a very good prospect. How about judging a player on production. I thought that was how it was done.

dumpsathernow* is offline