: News Article:
Mathieu Schneider and conditional pick to MTL for 2nd round (2009) + 3rd round (2010)
View Single Post
03-03-2009, 11:09 AM
Fish on The Sand
Join Date: Feb 2002
Originally Posted by
Well, I'm here to eat some crow. But I will also clarify my position. My original position was that I didn't think Schneider was the answer, but that I would give him a chance; regardless, I felt as though Gainey had overpaid.
Suffice to say I think Schneider's blown everyone away thus far. He hasn't been the sole reason for our success, but I think it would be foolish to ignore the tremendous impact he has had on our powerplay. So I was wrong to characterise the deal as one of desperation, though I doubt even Gainey thought he was getting this much out of Schneider.
Nonetheless, in terms of addressing needs and team weaknesses, I think Gainey did a tremendous job with this deal. Schneider is doing exactly what we want (and more) and he's filling a need the team we desperately needed. This is what you want your GMs to do, and kudos to Gainey for making this happen.
That being said
, I still think he overpaid, especially if you look at the recent deal for Havelid. Havelid is not only a superior player to Schneider but he also has a more manageable contract, which should lead people to believe that he carries higher value. Unless Salmela is truly a diamond in the rough, NJ filled a need for next to nothing. Havelid wouldn't fill the PP need on our team, so I can understand Gainey not pursuing him, but I still think that when you look at both deals Montreal paid a significantly higher price to address a weakness than NJ did.
Still, all in all I'm still very pleased with what Schneider has brought to this team.
Havelid is a much different kind of dman than Schneider. A better example would be to look at what ottawa gave up for Campoli.
Fish on The Sand
View Public Profile
Fish on The Sand's albums
Find More Posts by Fish on The Sand