View Single Post
03-13-2009, 09:24 PM
Paranoid Android
Paranoid Android's Avatar
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: CO
Posts: 11,786
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by worstfaceoffmanever View Post
Not hardly. The Predators had superior goaltending to Tampa Bay's Johan Holmqvist despite playing musical goalies with an uncomfortable frequency. They had Martin Erat and Vernon Fiddler on their second line, compared to Michel Ouellet and a floundering Jan Hlavac (just 22 points) on Tampa Bay's. Two of those four players aren't even in the NHL right now (although, admittedly, Hlavac chose to return to Europe). Our third line of Gelinas-Nichol-Tootoo outproduced their third line of Darche-Gratton-Jason Ward. It was Darche's only season as an NHL regular, and Ward cleared waivers earlier this season. He has 9 points in 21 AHL games.

I would venture to say that Weber and Boyle cancel each other out: similar offensive numbers (albeit with a discrepancy in games played) and similar overall seasons. Ranger, Kuba, and O'Brien (their top 3 for much of the season) could hardly be considered superior to Hamhuis, Zidlicky, and Suter with their play last season, particularly O'Brien, who was a walking penalty magnet. Lukowich and De Vries were/are about on par with one another. Zanon is better than Lundin. I would dare to say that Koistinen is at least as good as, if not superior to Doug Janik.

Outside of the clubs' respective first scoring units, 07/08 Nashville was a superior team to 07/08 Tampa Bay. The forwards were by and large defensively capable, the defensemen were defensively capable (Suter did battle consistency issues early in the year but really came around as the season progressed), and Ellis and Mason were far better than Holmqvist and Ramo, respectively.
I was half joking when I said that. Of course they are not word-for-word the same team. I'd be interested to hear your response to SLake's post, though.

Paranoid Android is offline   Reply With Quote