Thread: Proposal: Ott-tor
View Single Post
Old
04-05-2009, 07:38 AM
  #26
zenator
Registered User
 
zenator's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 1,755
vCash: 500
counter offer:

Chris Phillips + 2010 1st round pick + 2009 2nd round pick

for

Luke Schenn + 2009 3rd round pick



This deal would never be done by the Leafs, just as the Sens would never do the first deal.

It makes no sense to trade 6-7 years of a very promising youngster for 2 years of the older guy.

These deals would make sense IF the Leafs/Sens were Boston: in immediate cup contention. It would be like a Nieuwendyk - Iginla trade.

Schenn is obviously more proven than Karlsson, but given the TSN 7th rank, Karlsson is projected to be as good offensively as Schenn is defensively.

Also, Kaberle > Phillips

That's why the Sens give 2 draft picks, while the Leafs only gave a 2nd rounder in their deal.

zenator is offline   Reply With Quote