View Single Post
05-31-2009, 04:07 PM
Join Date: Jun 2005
Originally Posted by
Doughty Number 8
As for the original trade proposal, Rask really isn't much better (and far less NHL proven) than Quick, we have a multitude of other goaltending prospects, we don't need a guy like Ference, and Frolov is simply much, much better than Kobasew.
Not to mention that you throw Johnson in as well
Simply a terrible proposal, really really bad. Like, probably the worst I have seen that was a serious poster
Read it again. I didn't propose it, and I agree with most of what you say.
My one difference is on the Quick/Rask comparison. Quick does have more NHL experience, but I do think Rask will be a better goalie. Look, I like Quick a lot and have for years. He played prep school very close to where relatives of mine live so I've been aware of him since then. Plus he played college hockey at my alma mater. I like him a lot. However, I do think Bernier is the better long term prospect and i think Rask is (slightly) better than Bernier.
That's my opinion.
View Public Profile
Dr Quincy's albums
Find More Posts by Dr Quincy