View Single Post
Old
07-29-2009, 01:55 PM
  #50
JawandaPuck
Moderator
Lost Art of Dynasty
 
JawandaPuck's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Vancouver BC
Country: Canada
Posts: 4,294
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by jtbolts87 View Post
1. Hedman
2. Ashton
3. Downie
4. Lashoff
5. Panik
6. Wishart
7. Tokarski
8. Tyrell
9. Helenius
10. Harju
11. Ramo
12. Szczechura
13. Hutchings
14. Killorn
15. Karsums
16. Mihalik
17. Fadden
18. Smolenak
19. Quick
20. Tukonen
Missed: Barberio

I also feel the HF list reflects potential more then how close a player is to actually being in the NHL. That is why some disagree.

Below is how I would Group & Rank the TB prospects. I've left intact the HF rank and grade, and added your rank in (), for comparison purposes.

Tier One
  1. 1. Victor Hedman, D – 9.0C (1)

    Tier Two
  2. 11. Steve Downie, C – 7.0C (3)
  3. 9. Ty Wishart, D – 7.0C (6)
  4. 4. Matt Lashoff, D – 7.5C (4)
  5. 2. Carter Ashton, C – 7.5C (2)
  6. 5. Dana Tyrell, C – 7.0C (8)
  7. NR. Riku Helenius, G (9)
  8. 3. Richard Panik, C - 7.5D (5)
  9. 8. Vladimir Mihalik, D – 7.0C (16)
  10. 17. Mark Barberio, D - 6.5C (missed)
  11. 6. Dustin Tokarski, G – 7.0C (7)

    Tier 3 & 4
  12. 15. Blair Jones, C – 6.5C (NR)
  13. 16. Johan Harju, LW - 7.0C (10)
  14. 12. Paul Szczechura, C – 6.5C (12)
  15. 10. Martins Karsums, RW- 6.5C (15)
  16. 13. Mitch Fadden, C – 7.0C (17)
  17. 14. Alex Hutchings, C – 7.0D (13)
  18. 18. Radek Smolenak, LW – 6.5D (18)
  19. 19. Lauri Tukonen, RW - 7.0D (20)
  20. 7. Karri Ramo, G – 7.0C (11)
  21. 20. Alex Killorn, LW - 7.0D (14)


BTW, I am high on Ashton but would need to see a little more of him to put him above some of those who have played more seasons.

I would be interested in seeing how others rank the TB prospect pool.

JawandaPuck is offline