View Single Post
Old
08-31-2009, 05:41 PM
  #40
MXD
Registered User
 
MXD's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Ottawa
Posts: 21,077
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shirtless Joe View Post
Defensemen:

Dit Clapper was voted to the first or second AST as a defenseman more often than as a winger, so I'm listing him here. The AST selections at forward were in 30-31 and 34-35, and the AST selections at D started in 38-39.

King Clancy started his NHL career in 1921-22, and all-star teams were first selected in 1930-31.

All-star team selections

Player First AST Second AST Total
King Clancy 2 2 4
Dit Clapper 3 3 6
Tim Horton 3 3 6
Pierre Pilote 5 3 8
Earl Seibert 4 6 10

Norris voting

Season First Second Third
1961-62 Harvey Pilote Talbot
1962-63 Pilote Brewer Horton
1963-64 Pilote Horton Vasko
1964-65 Pilote Laperriere Gadsby
1965-66 Laperriere Pilote Stapleton
1966-67 Howell Pilote Orr

Season First Second Third
1962-63 Pilote Brewer Horton
1963-64 Pilote Horton Vasko
1967-68 Orr Tremblay Horton
1968-69 Orr Horton Green

Hart voting

Season First Second Third Fourth Fifth
1926-27 Gardiner Cook Frederickson Irvin Clancy
1928-29 Worters Bailey Shore Mantha Clancy
1929-30 Stewart Hitchman Weiland Clancy Boucher
1930-31 Morenz Shore Clancy Goodfellow Stewart
1933-34 Joliat L. Conacher Clancy Seibert Worters

Season First Second Third Fourth Fifth
1933-34 Joliat L. Conacher Clancy Seibert Worters
1943-44 Pratt Cowley D. Bentley Seibert Carr

Season First Second Third Fourth Fifth
1939-40 Goodfellow Apps Clapper Schmidt Robinson
1940-41 Cowley Clapper Apps Howe Hextall

Career regular season scoring compared to (somewhat) contemporary defensemen

Player Seasons GP G A TP PPG PIM
King Clancy 1921-1937 592 136 147 283 0.48 914
Ebbie Goodfellow 1929-1937 369 107 135 242 0.66 390
Eddie Shore 1926-1937 444 94 147 241 0.54 945

Player Seasons GP G A TP PPG PIM
Dit Clapper 1927-1947 833 228 246 474 0.57 462
Ebbie Goodfellow 1929-1943 557 134 190 324 0.58 511
Flash Hollett 1933-1946 562 132 181 313 0.56 358

Player Seasons GP G A TP PPG PIM
Flash Hollett 1933-1946 562 132 181 313 0.56 358
Babe Pratt 1935-1946 486 79 205 284 0.58 438
Earl Seibert 1931-1946 645 89 187 276 0.43 746

Player Seasons GP G A TP PPG PIM
Red Kelly 1949-1967 1197 270 517 787 0.66 304
Bill Gadsby 1949-1966 1090 113 408 521 0.48 1357
Tim Horton 1949-1974 1446 115 403 518 0.36 1611

Player Seasons GP G A TP PPG PIM
Red Kelly 1955-1967 788 172 334 506 0.64 201
Pierre Pilote 1955-1969 890 80 418 498 0.56 1251
Tim Horton 1955-1969 914 92 283 375 0.41 1025

Thanks for the correction about Northcott, seventieslord. No comments about Goodfellow being listed as a defensemen? With players like Clapper and Goodfellow, I'm not really sure where to draw the line.
I think you just screwed Goodfellow's D and C years. Was a C, was then converted to a D in 35-36. (Barry's arrival, anyone?)


Last edited by MXD: 08-31-2009 at 05:59 PM.
MXD is offline   Reply With Quote