View Single Post
Old
09-01-2009, 01:40 AM
  #86
Howe Elbows 9
Registered User
 
Howe Elbows 9's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Gävle, Sweden
Posts: 2,524
vCash: 700
Quote:
Originally Posted by MXD View Post
I think you just screwed Goodfellow's D and C years. Was a C, was then converted to a D in 35-36. (Barry's arrival, anyone?)
Here's what I edited into my post on page 1;

Player Seasons GP G A TP PPG PIM
King Clancy 1921-1937 592 136 147 283 0.48 914
Eddie Shore 1926-1937 444 94 147 241 0.54 945
Hap Day 1924-1937 538 86 113 199 0.37 587

Sure, Day also tried a forward position for a short while, but that was just a short part of his NHL career. Because Clapper and Goodfellow both spent considerable amounts of time at both positions, I'm keeping that comparison in my post.

Moving on to the goalies:

In the case of Benedict, only his NHL years are considered in this post. Some information similar to what I'm posting may have been posted earlier in this thread.

Top 3 in shutouts
Season First Second Third
1917-18 Benedict, Vezina  
1918-19 Benedict Vezina 
1919-20 Benedict  
1920-21 Benedict Lockhart, Vezina 
1921-22 Benedict  
1922-23 Benedict Vezina Roach
1923-24 Benedict, Vezina Forbes, Roach 
1925-26 Connell Worters Benedict, Stewart
1926-27 Hainsworth Benedict, Connell 
1937-38 Kerr Thompson Broda, Robertson
1938-39 Brimsek Broda Kerr
1939-40 Kerr Brimsek, Robertson 
1940-41 Brimsek Broda Mowers
1941-42 Broda Mowers Brimsek, LoPresti
1942-43 Mowers Beveridge, Bibeault, Brimsek, Broda, B. Gardiner 
1943-44 Bibeault Karakas Durnan
1944-45 Karakas, McCool Durnan, Lumley, McAuley 
1945-46 Durnan Bibeault, Brimsek, Lumley 
1946-47 Rayner Broda, Durnan 
1947-48 Lumley Broda, Durnan 
1948-49 Durnan Rayner Lumley
1949-50 Broda Durnan Lumley
1950-51 Sawchuk Broda, McNeil 

Summary
Player First Second Third Total
Benedict 7 1 1 9
Broda 2 6 1 9
Durnan 2 3 2 7

Top 3 in GAA
Season First Second Third
1917-18 Vezina Holmes Benedict
1918-19 Benedict Vezina Lindsay
1919-20 Benedict Mitchell Vezina
1920-21 Benedict Forbes Vezina
1921-22 Benedict Vezina Roach
1922-23 Benedict Vezina Roach
1923-24 Vezina Benedict Forbes
1924-25 Vezina Forbes Benedict
1925-26 Connell Worters Benedict
1926-27 Benedict Chabot Hainsworth
1938-39 Brimsek Kerr Broda
1939-40 Kerr Goodman Brimsek
1940-41 Broda Brimsek, Mowers 
1941-42 Brimsek Broda Henry
1942-43 Mowers Broda Brimsek
1943-44 Durnan Bibeault Karakas
1944-45 Durnan Lumley McCool
1945-46 Durnan Bibeault Lumley
1946-47 Durnan Broda Brimsek
1947-48 Broda Lumley Durnan
1948-49 Durnan Lumley Broda
1949-50 Durnan Lumley Broda
1950-51 Rollins Sawchuk Broda

Summary
Player First Second Third Total
Benedict 6 1 3 10
Broda 2 3 4 9
Durnan 6 0 1 7

Moving on to another topic, here are the top 6 in Soviet MVP votes:

Player First Second Third Fourth Fifth Total
Tretiak 5 2 3 2 12
Makarov 3 2 2 3 10
Fetisov 2 2 3 1 1 9
Mikhailov 2 1 2 1 2 8
Kharlamov 1 3 2 2 8
Maltsev 1 2 1 4 8

And the years when Mikhailov was considered among the top 5:

Year 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th
1969 Firsov (CSKA) Zinger (Spartak) Starshinov (Spartak) Kharlamov (CSKA) Mikhailov (CSKA)
1973 Kharlamov (CSKA) Petrov (CSKA) Tretiak (CSKA) Mikhailov (CSKA) Vasiliev (Dynamo)
1974 Tretiak (CSKA) Mikhailov (CSKA) Vasiliev (Dynamo) Maltsev (Dynamo) Kharlamov (CSKA)
1975 Tretiak (CSKA) Kharlamov (CSKA) Yakushev (Spartak) Petrov (CSKA) Mikhailov (CSKA)
1977 Balderis (Riga) Petrov (CSKA) Mikhailov (CSKA), Tretiak (CSKA) Vassili (Dynamo)
1978 Mikhailov (CSKA) Tretiak (CSKA) Fetisov (CSKA) Maltsev (Dynamo) Balderis (CSKA)
1979 Mikhailov (CSKA)     
1980 Makarov (CSKA) Krutov (CSKA) Mikhailov (CSKA) Maltsev (Dynamo) Vasiliev (Dynamo)

For 1979, no data about voting aside from the winner is avaliable.


Last edited by Howe Elbows 9: 09-01-2009 at 05:27 AM.
Howe Elbows 9 is offline   Reply With Quote