View Single Post
Old
11-29-2009, 06:06 PM
  #76
jarek
Registered User
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 4,550
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leaf Lander View Post
if paul coffey was on my team would had still lost the series

old players are great but we are guessing with them


and when a current great is choosen over oen wit ha longer resumee igice credit where i can I dont guess



All tiem greats drop i my lists of great players because of their small amount of games played

They only get incluided when you consider there greatness for there era

The game wasn't even very evolved in soem cases

Many would not last in atd format
but that's just my sober opinion


and no i do not drink
But why does it matter that they played fewer games? It isn't their fault that the schedules were short. They did great things with the short amount of time they had to do them. The rest is all relative.

We assume that they can adjust to an 82 game schedule, or else even a guy like Cyclone Taylor is junk. Have you seen the kind of equipment they used to wear? I could go outside during winter with my clothes, a toque, a winter jacket and track pants, and I'd be more protected from a puck hitting me than they were. We assume that they can adjust to modern equipment, modern rules, modern everything. Where does this put a guy like Eddie Shore, who wouldn't survive 2 games in the modern game without adjusting for relativity. Those guys used to crack each other over the head with their sticks, and this was considered tough hockey back then that, to my knowledge, didn't even lead to fines. Marty McSorley, for example, was banned from the league for hitting Donald Brasher in the head with his stick. This was a REGULAR OCCURRANCE in the PCHA/NHA days. How would a guy like Jack Walker survive without adjusting for relativity, or Frank Nighbor? Both of them used hook checks as their defensive asset. It was legal back then, but these days if you even think about hooking a guy, you get penalized for it. Almost all of this is under the assumption that everyone from earlier eras can adjust, or else I'd be drafting Wade Belak and Aki Berg before drafting Moose Johnson or Art Ross.

jarek is offline   Reply With Quote