View Single Post
Old
09-22-2003, 03:49 PM
  #7
Peter Griffin
Registered User
 
Peter Griffin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 26,696
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by mdoak
Package Satan and Zhitnik for a young, somewhat cheap (3-4 million) #1 d-man and top notch prospect from a team who is looking to win the cup THIS season. they can dump the salary of Zhitnik after this season and can keep Satan long term.
Why would a team that is looking to challenge for the cup trade away a #1 d-man, unless of course they are loaded with them, which no team is. It doesn't make sense IMO as it would just open up another hole,a harder hole to fill. Zhitnik isn't a #1 d-man and is probably at best a #3 on most top teams in the league.

Quote:
To Buffalo: Jovonowski/Ohlund and Fedorov
To Vancouver: Satan and Zhintik

Buffalo gets their #1 D-man, Vancouver gets great scoring from the 2nd line. Zhitnik takes over the #2 spot for whichever d-man Buffalo gets.
I wouldn't even consider that deal from a Canucks' perspective. I like Satan and would love to have him on the Canucks, but #1 d-man are far to valuable in this league, and the Canucks, or any contending team for that matter, can't afford to trade one away.

The best bet to get a #1 d-man or someone who could become a #1 guy is the Isles IMO. They could use some offensive help and could part with Roman Hamrlik to get it. Could be a fit there, maybe something like this:

To Buffalo:

Roman Hamrlik
Dave Scatchard
pick/prospect


To Islanders

Miroslav Satan
Jay McKee

Just a thought...

Peter Griffin is offline