View Single Post
12-26-2004, 07:05 PM
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 4,671
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by littleHossa
I started thinking what Phaneuf would look like in a Sens uniform, just like the other 29 teams also are and here's a proposal, I don't do this often but try to keep it constructive, we can skip the "player is the franchise and I hate you..."

Ottawa gives:
Havlat(cheaper and younger)
Meszaros(upside similar enough to Phaneuf and also close to being NHL ready)
1st rounder or Vermette(evens the deal out, good assets)

Calgary gives:
Iginla(gritty 1st liner and leadership)
Phaneuf(some more hitting power)
#1 Iginla is arguably the best all around forward in the league. To get someone of his calibre (and he hasn't hit his prime) would cost Havlat + a top prosect alone (ie. Spezza).

#2 Phaneuf is mroe than ready for the NHL. Sutter has said hismelf he would be playing in the NHL if there was a season. Phaneuf > Meszaros

Iginla = Havlat + 1st + prospect

Phaneuf > Meszaros

The deal is not even close.

HuskyFlames is offline