Thread: Proposal: Col - Stl
View Single Post
Old
02-08-2010, 06:25 PM
  #21
camarodude39
Registered User
 
camarodude39's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 228
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheOrganist View Post
First of all Petro is the only elite defensive prospect we have. Don't put Junland and Cole in his category. Petro is the only D prospect we need to "find a spot for."

Not all of these kids are going to don the Bluenote. Junland has put up numbers in the A but his looked shaky during his limited time in the show and his skating is awkward. There's not much in his skill set that says he will be a top defenseman and big contributor in the future.

Cole is a guy I haven't been impressed with since I saw him at his first prospect camp after we drafted him. His apparent desire to not spend much time in the minors and his concussion problem is only exacerbating my belief that he will not be with the team long term.

The Blues transition game and mobility on the blue line is still the Blues biggest problem by far. Liles, Petro and EJ quickly turn a weakness into a strength and a player like Liles, who is in his prime, is something this team badly needs. He's a legit offensive defenseman, great skater, great puck mover. Not a wannabe like Carlo.

We all know how one-dimensional Boyes is and he's been nothing short of awful from Day 1. The worst player on the team this year in my opinion. But GM's salivate over goals, and Boyes does have a track record of production, so he still has value around the league.

I understand fans of other teams who don't watch many Blues games probably think Boyes' value > Liles right now, but Boyes has been horrible this year.

It's 2 underachieving players who happen to make the same money and whose assets help the teams they are being traded to in this hypothetical deal more than their current teams.
Whether you think they are going to make it or not, you have to expect them to get a shot at the NHL soon to see what they have in those players. Looking at the blueline next season, you would have:

Brewer
Jackman
Polak
EJ
Petro
Liles
Strachan(RFA)
Cole
Junland

All of those guys would be expected to fight for a roster spot. That gives 9 d-men, if we acquire Liles. It would do no good for Junland, Petro, or Cole to sit every night as a healthy scratch with that depth, so you would have to assume 2 of those 3 guys would be sent to Peoria(something I dont know that Cole will be willing to do, and Junland might be getting tired of), and yet another depth defensemen would be needed to be signed, giving us potentially 10 d-men under contract. That is a whole heck of a lot of defensemen....I think the offers in this thread all seem pretty fair, but doesnt really answer the Blues biggest need, which is an impact scoring forward.

camarodude39 is offline   Reply With Quote