Jeff Carter to Calgary
View Single Post
02-18-2010, 06:56 PM
Gert B Frobe
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Morgantown PA
Originally Posted by
im sick of giroux on the 3rd line i think we need to compact our talent into 2 lines, cut this 3 line BS
giroux JVR carter richards briere gagne hartnell
7 good guys, but we need 6 for two lines, not 7 for three.
IMO we should trade 1 (hartnell, gags, briere) for a good dman and a 3rd line grinder, but i think i've made that point...
gags richie carter
JVR briere giroux (flip briere and giroux?)
thing with giroux/briere is that they are both competant at wing and center and are both pretty small, i'd take giroux up the middle over briere though.
Yup I agree - the problem is - Hartnell has a NTC and his contract is pretty bad, Gagne has horrible value right now and Briere's contract is borderline obscene. I doubt the Flyers could get a good dman alone for any of those players - let alone a good dman and a 3rd liner. Those guys are just more valuable to Philly than to anybody else right now.
To get Carter - the Flames would have to give up Regehr and maybe somebody like Glencross (I guess) but the Flyers don't really need Regehr and a third liner - this trade would definitely make the Flyers worse.
Last edited by Gert B Frobe: 02-18-2010 at
Gert B Frobe
View Public Profile
Gert B Frobe's albums
Find More Posts by Gert B Frobe