PS #5 - 10.01.2010 | Ottawa Senators @ New York Rangers | 7:00 PM - MSG (HD)
View Single Post
10-01-2010, 04:29 PM
Join Date: Jun 2010
Originally Posted by
Unbunch your panties. I only took one line as an example. I'm not going to sit here and rank the entire team an
when the fact of the matter is we aren't an
team or have
lines. I took the Atlantic division as an example b/c that's where we are situated last time I checked. If you want to use the entire league that's even more against you and your grades. I don't know why you got so defensive, but just so you quit your hissy fit I will grade everything.
; Frolov is a good player but has proven to be erratic with his play at times. Prospal is an aging vet who hasn't produced at consistent rates season in/out & is facing injuries. Prospal also is not an established 1c, not even close. Gaborik is the elite talent.
- ; Dubinsky as of yet has not cracked 50 pts. However, he was on pace but the fact remains he has not cracked the 50 mark. Anisimov is a sophmore coming off a whopping 38 points, history does suggest he will improve his totals. His camp also suggests a better season. Callahan is a 3rd liner on a stanley cup champion team, at best he's a 20-20 guy. Maybe 25-20.
; A lot of question marks. Will Avery find his game, will Fedotenko find his game? You also have a rookie centering the line; how will he fare in a 82 game schedule.
4th Line: B ; Alot depends whether or not Boyle has found something.
D2: Rozsival-Del Zotto
These rankings are based on our talent compared to other teams in the league. Yours I think are based on wishful thinking.
He was wrong and didn't even realize you said "For example". Instead of shouting him into a corner which is an all too common sight on these boards you answered his question logically. Awesome job and your forward line ranks were pretty spot on. But I can't believ how high you ranked the D pairs. Staal and Girardi I mean Staal is Staal but I'm not sure if that line is A-. I guess it's close but is Girardi that good?
Then the Roszi DZ A- shocked me. I love DZ but that D inefficiency combined with DZ;s youth makes me think C+. Can't argue with your forward ranks at all. Were you just keeping his D ranks? Maybe I misread it then.
Last edited by JimmyStart*: 10-01-2010 at
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by JimmyStart*