Argument against Andreychuk
View Single Post
05-05-2005, 10:28 AM
Join Date: Apr 2005
Originally Posted by
A guy like Scott Mellanby was 'just good'.
For a 21 year period 1981-2002, Francis
62 assists/82 games played. He
led the league
in assists twice. He had seasons where he finished 4th and 5th in league scoring, and several in the top 10. Far and beyond 'just good'.
Take away the pure statistical numbers if you like. Forget that he had more assists than most HHOFers had points. This is a guy who finished top-5 or so in assists in the NHL pretty much every year for 20 years, and led the league on multiple occasions. This is excellence, end of story. Any way you slice it, this is one of the best playmakers the game of hockey has ever seen. Regardless of era - lop off 20% of his assists to adjust for the time period and he still has 1000 assists, and is ahead of pretty much everyone else ever to play the game save Gretzky.
Never mind that, on top of being one of the games elite playmaking centers for 20 years, he was also one of the league's top defensive forwards, winning a Selke and being a finalist for that award on several occasions.
Mellanby was average. I'll bump Francis up to "very good".
In my world, he is highly overrated. But, many people don't want to look past the numbers and see the truth of what they represent. Fine by me. I choose to see the truth.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Ogopogo*