: Prospect Info:
2010 Flyers Prospects & Phantoms Discussion Thread
View Single Post
12-01-2010, 01:22 AM
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Lumberton, NJ
Originally Posted by
I'd still rather have Pronger, Carle and Carcillo than Lupul, Sbisa, Downie, Carlson and Upshall. In fact, I'd rather have just Pronger than the other 5.....
Malakhov cost us Pavelec.
Gauthier cost us Matthias and Emmerton.
Biron cost us Brennan.
Timonen and Hartnell cost us Blum.
Prospal cost us Panik.
Sbisa and Bourdon cost us Umberger.
Patrick Hersley and Ned Lukacevic cost us Gauthier and Zucker.
Carcillo cost us Upshall and a 2011 2nd.
Eminger cost us Carlson.
Carle cost us Downie and Eminger (Carlson).
Pronger cost us Sbisa, Lupul, Palmieri, and Etem.
Meszaros cost us 2012 2nd.
Don't trade for Gauthier and we get:
Don't trade for Malakhov and we get:
Don't trade for Eminger and we get:
Well, we keep Downie and we don't get Carle basically.
Those are the only avoidable trades. Biron made sense. Timonen and Hartnell made sense. I guess Prospal made sense. Pronger was completely necessary, and Meszaros was a great deal for us.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by CS