ATD 2011 Draft Thread III
View Single Post
02-07-2011, 04:31 PM
Join Date: Nov 2009
Originally Posted by
In theory, in the exact same seasons, with all things being equal, yes, the guy who was 1st once and 9th another time would have done better on the aggregate (i.e. maybe he finishes 25 points ahead of 5th when he's 1st, but just 12 points behind 5th when he's 9th) - but I also don't think that was the point he was trying to make at all... at least I hope not. What an awful thing to argue about !
I don't think it would.
You need to compare everything to a known value and not change the goalposts year by year.
I could select random placements from different generations too, and show that they are all exactly 70% away from eachother but I have better things to do - like pick my nose.
Probably the best thing you can do is put it into practice. Next time you need to compare your player to someone else's, try out what you're saying. I think it would be a mess. When you're done that, try using a comparison to #2 as a benchmark. You'll like it a lot better, I reckon.
Yeah really. That's basically what I said in the last paragraph of my post. That made it incredibly confusing.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Derick*