View Single Post
Old
06-30-2011, 07:13 PM
  #484
BM67
Registered User
 
BM67's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: In "The System"
Country: Canada
Posts: 4,553
vCash: 500
Made the change of Roach to Northcott at 3rd in Hart voting as noted in several papers. Added Haynes at 3rd in Lady Byng voting also mentioned in one of the papers.

1932-33
HART: (213)
1. Eddie Shore, Bos D 86
2. Bill Cook, NYR RW 67
3. Baldy Northcott, Mtl M LW 60
Points totals from NHL Awards pdf file that lists John Roach, Det G as 3rd.
CALDER:
1. Carl Voss, Det C
LADY BYNG:
1. Frank Boucher, NYR C
2. Joe Primeau, Tor C
3. Paul Haynes, Mtl M C

Added the missing votes for Hart and Lady Byng, as well as the vote split for McFadden in the Calder voting.

1947-48
HART: (108/108, 15-12-10)
1. Buddy O'Connor, NYR C 36 (10-2-2)
2. Frank Brimsek, Bos G 18 (2-4-4)
3. Elmer Lach, Mtl C 13 (1-5-0)
4. Max Bentley, Tor C 10 (2-1-2)
T5. Ted Lindsay, Det LW 7
T5. Syl Apps, Tor C 7
T5. Ted Kennedy, Tor C 7
T8. Gaye Stewart, Chi LW 3
T8. Milt Schmidt, Bos C 3
10. Bill Quackenbush, Det D 2
T11. Doug Bentley, Chi LW 1 (0-0-1)
T11. Sid Abel, Det C 1 (0-0-1)
CALDER: (106/108, 16-1-0)
1. Jim McFadden, Det C 50 (16-1-0)
2. Pete Babando, Bos LW 22
3. Red Kelly, Det D 14
T4. Don Raleigh, NYR C 8
T4. Ed Sanford, Bos C 8
6. Bill Barilko, Tor D 4
LADY BYNG: (108/108, 16-14-13)
1. Buddy O'Connor, Mtl C 32 (9-2-1)
2. Syl Apps Sr., Tor C 16 (2-4-2)
3. Roy Conacher, Chi LW 15 (2-3-3)
4. Edgar Laprade, NYR C 14 (2-3-2)
5. Jim Conacher, Det C 10 (1-2-3)
6. Bill Quackenbush, Det D 5
7. Max Bentley, Tor C 4
T8. Jim McFadden, Det C 3
T8. Woody Dumart, Bos LW 3
T10. Doug Bentley, Chi LW 2
T10. Harry Lumley, Det G 2
T12. Jack Crawford, Bos D 1 (0-0-1)
T12. Gus Bodnar, Chi C 1 (0-0-1)

Only six players received votes for the Calder, so either the two missing points are lost due to rounding from the weighted voting, or there is an error in someones total. I have added two points to Brimsek's total in Hart voting, as there were also two points missing, but his votes as given by the NHL Awards file add up to 18.

BM67 is online now   Reply With Quote