View Single Post
Old
07-16-2011, 07:39 PM
  #79
Yakushev72
Registered User
 
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 2,421
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBakester66 View Post
Pushkin, what on earth does that have to do with him being one of the best hockey players in the history of Russia? I don't care if he played in Switzerland National League A his whole career and never played a single Olympic or World Championship game, if he had one of the best careers of all time (of course it would be difficult to do this in the NLA and without playing in Olympics, etc.), then he should belong in the top 50.

On another note, someone else got bashed for mentioning Sushinsky, so this can't go over well either, but he has played for the Russian WC team a number of times, albeit to luke warm results. But no love for Sergei Mozyakin? I mean compared to basically every player mentioned so far, i wouldn't include him. I would argue he would struggle in the NHL with his style of play, but he has been one of the most dominant RSL offensive forwards of the past 10 years. I guess Alexei Morozov would be in the same boat, and lord knows i wouldn't put him in a top 50.

I love the comments on the Latvians (Balderis, Ozolinsh, etc.). Ozolinsh shouldn't count because he never played for Russia. But i don't understand how Balderis doesn't count when everyone seems to be counting play for team USSR or team Russia in WC, WJC, Olympic, Canada Cup play as a bonus for other players. Oh, and lol about the Irbe comment. Does Nabokov not count by the same token? I guess the OP said you can do the regions outside of Russia in the USSR seperately. If that's the case, lets come up with a list with none of the non-Russian borns on the list.
The reason Balderis and Ozolinsh are not considered among the top 50 Russians is that they are not Russians. Russian and Latvia are different countries, and Balderis and Ozolinsh are ethnic Latvians, not Russians. Furthermore, Ozolinsh would get nowhere near the top 50 all-time even if he was a Russian!

Morozov, Sushinsky and Mozyakin are good players in the KHL, but they don't even deserve consideration as being near the top 50 Russian hockey players of all time. There were at least 50 Russians who played in the Soviet era alone who were better than they ever were.

Yakushev72 is online now   Reply With Quote