MLD2011 Finals - Eden Hall Warriors vs Regina Capitals
View Single Post
09-07-2011, 11:36 PM
Join Date: Aug 2006
Originally Posted by
Point 2: Don't you? If we only want to look at the good seasons that players played, then why do we count the seasons that players played poorly and use it against them when it comes time to arguing? Specifically, poor playoffs. How do we even determine what "prime" is? When they get good? So in other words, when it's convenient. The awful seasons that players had don't just disappear, and they should certainly count for something.. otherwise, what's the point of continuing the draft after Bobby Orr gets taken? Nobody could stop Orr in his prime.
Orr only won 2 Cups - the Flyers and Canadiens both beat him in his prime.
Whatever "prime" is, it's clear Campbell wasn't in it before the lockout.
I'm not defending Gibbs here, I'm pointing out the flaws in your logic, and how they can be used against you in the same way. What Gibbs did not do is what Gibbs did not do, but Gibbs also did quite a lot of good things in his career too. If he was leading his teams in ice time for so many years, that means SOMETHING, doesn't it? The same argument you're trying to use for Campbell..
Leading a team in ice time means something. Leading a good team in ice time means more.
Interesting results. Seems like he did fine at ES, but struggled to ever find his way on the PK units.
Is Ehrhoff a regular on Eden Hall's PK units?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by TheDevilMadeMe