View Single Post
Old
09-18-2011, 06:20 PM
  #1
kingsfan
#SutterforanOscar
 
kingsfan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Manitoba, Canada
Country: Canada
Posts: 8,724
vCash: 500
Prospects this year and last year as voted by you

Just wanted to compare this years fanbased poll with last years. This is the top 20 prospects as we voted on them over the last few weeks:

1st: Andrei Loktionov 39.66% (runner up: Viatcheslav Voinov 31.03%)
2nd: Viatcheslav Voinov 79.63% (runner up: Tyler Toffoli 12.96%)
3rd: Tyler Toffoli 53.57% (runner up: Derek Forbort 16.07%)
4th: Derek Forbort 55.88% (runner up: Nicholas Deslauriers 20.59%)
5th: Nicholas Deslauriers 48.57% (runner up: Martin Jones 15.71%)
6th: Martin Jones 27.87% (runner up Thomas Hickey 26.23%)
7th: Thomas Hickey 34.92% (runner up Jake Muzzin 23.81%)
8th: Jake Muzzin 35.71% (runner up Maxim Kitsyn 21.43%)
9th: Maxim Kitsyn 30.19% (runners up: Brandon Kozun and Linden Vey 26.42%)
10th: Brandon Kozun 46.51% (runner up Linden Vey 25.58%)
11th: Linden Vey 46.81% (runner up: Christopher Gibson 31.91%)
12th: Christopher Gibson 70.45% (runner up: George "Bud" Holloway 9.09%)
13th: Oscar Moller 53.66% (runner up Jordan Weal 12.20%)
14th: George "Bud" Holloway 46.34% (runners up: Jordan Weal and Nick Shore 12.20%)
15th: Jordan Weal 30.77% (runner up: Nick Shore 19.23%)
16th: Nick Shore 38.64% (runner up: Jeff Zatkoff 20.45%)
17th: Jeff Zatkoff 28.57% (runner up: Dwight King 17.14%)
18th: Andy Andreoff 50% (runner up: Dwight King 14.29%)
19th: Dwight King 29.17% (runner up: Michael Schumacher 20.83%)
20th: Michael Schumacher 36.67% (runner up: Andrew Campbell and Jean-Francois Berube 13.33%)

And this is last year (can be found here as well: http://hfboards.com/showthread.php?t=819934 )

1. Bernier- 87.21%
2. Schenn- 86.36%
3. Hickey- 62.22%
4. Forbort- 36.36%
5. Vyacheslav Voynov- 35.96%
6. Loktionov- 63.16%
7. Clifford- 56.47%
8. Teubert- 34.38%
9. Deslauriers- 29.35%
10. Kozun- 32.47%
11. Toffoli- 28.21%
12. Jones- 29.41%
13. Muzzin- 37.35%
14. Zatkoff- 50.85%
15. Lewis- 31.25%
16. Weal- 28.57%
17. Martinez- 34.48%
18. Holloway- 29.63%
19. Czarnik- 39.58%
20. Maxim Kitsyn- 50%

A few guys graduated, like Clifford, while I elected to consider Moller a prospect this year even though that didn't coincide with HF's standards, and others, like Teubert and Schenn were dealt. For the guys on both lists, some big risers and fallers though. Kitsyn jumped from 20th to 9th and Toffoli went from 11th to 3rd.

The thing I found the most interesting about the list the fans did last year is guys like Clifford (7th), Muzzin (13th), Lewis (15th) and Martinez (17th). All either started the season with the team or played the majority of the season with the team, yet we didn't feel they were worthy of top rankings. In Martinez's case, he almost didn''t get ranked.

What are your thoughts?

kingsfan is offline   Reply With Quote