Trade Rumors and Proposal Thread XVIII
View Single Post
10-28-2011, 05:18 PM
Join Date: Sep 2009
Originally Posted by
Which defenseman has more value to other GMs: Lee or Carkner?
Carkner? Tough, somewhat physical and a great vet to have in a team, Perfect bottom 6
Lee? Average Shutdown D, trying to be physical with still some potential to improve as a top 4.
I don't think Brian Lee really has any value because probably all 30 NHL teams have a D man that can do at least what Lee does. Maybe trade a 4th for him, but if we got Filatov for a 3rd, gotta think Lee is worth probably not much when most teams have least 1 guy in the system who can fill in.
So Carkner wins, at least he can fight, push and shove and kill Penalties and he has a presence to him on the ice that Lee doesn't have
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Tuna99