When Pilar comes back
View Single Post
11-03-2003, 11:55 AM
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Leaf Nation
Originally Posted by
+/- isn't the most reliable stat in the world, similiar to a goalies GAA or a pitchers ERA, the whole TEAM affects those stats, not just the player. If you go just by +/- Berg is the Leafs best defenseman.
First of all I'd like to hear you explain how a pitchers ERA is affected by the whole team, but that's beside the point.
No +/- isn't the most reliable stat in the world. But it can be useful if you apply it properly.
I've compared Kaberle's and Redden's +/- in the past. You can do that because they both play on good teams, they both play the same role on their respective teams and they both put up similar point totals.
But on the other hand, I'd never say Phillipe Boucher (+28) is better defensivly than Mattias Norstrom (+0). Boucher played on a stronger team, they have different roles on their team and Boucher scores more points.
Therefore, when you see that Jackman's +/- is consistently worse than his teammates and even his defence partners- yeah that means something.
View Public Profile
Leaf Army's albums
Find More Posts by Leaf Army