Leafs/Ducks Proposal (Rumour)
View Single Post
11-04-2003, 06:03 AM
Join Date: Oct 2003
Niedermayer is garbage - so is Tucker for that matter. I don't think any team wants Darcy at all. The guy is a cancer - all he does every game is whine to the refs about this call and that call. I would rather Ferguson just put the guy on waivers if he can't trade him.
Originally Posted by
to further clarify my fellow posters opinion
Niedermayer is the Ducks leading scorer
Ducks have difficulty scoring
Niedermayer is a guy who is getting it done
I don't think Tucker can fill that role
the Ducks have 8 d-men right now (well 7.5, Ward also plays forward)
If they trade a d-man, they would definitely not want another one back (unless it's a two for one deal)
and if they do get another one back, it shouldn't be of the "surplus" kind
To me the values are a bit screwy too, especially if you consider Vishnevski's potential. I think Niedermayer and Tucker are a wash (once this would be laughable, but Niedermayer has become a lot more valuable since the Ducks got him, IMO)
Vishnevksi for Berg/Hedin/Kondratiev favors Leafs IMO and plus the Ducks don't need another "surplus" guy
Your opinion on that move is just the opposite of mine, the Ducks would probably prefer a guy like Hedin or Kondratiev to put in the minors and develop then a guy like Berg who's already a known quantity. But the Ducks would be more interested in an offensive defenseman prospect. Ian White perhaps?
Maybe the value isn't as bad as I thought, but I can't see the Ducks trading Niedermayer without getting top 6 scoring talent in return. Tucker isn't that.
View Public Profile
BIG FAN's albums
Find More Posts by BIG FAN