All David Desharnais talk here.
View Single Post
01-16-2012, 04:30 PM
Join Date: Sep 2007
Originally Posted by
Holy s*** this is embarrassing. Take your blinders off!
The best way to evaluate your players is to get the opinion of other professional's around the league. DD might, *might* yield you a 3rd, if your lucky a late 2nd.
On to why.
In order for DD to be effective he needs to play against weaker competition and with offensive wingers. Please, just please put him with Darche and Moen for a change then he will feel what Eller does. Does anyone remember when Eller was with Patches and Cole? That line was fricken dynamite, and thats when Patches was playing awful (and it was worse with DD might I add). Eller is the superior talent in all 3 areas. Its pretty obvious to see that, try to take an objective view and you will notice it.
You all say that DD is so great offensively, okay so since he is averaging in the top of PP time, how good is our powerplay doing? Its top in the league right! Because DD is so creative and fast and has such great vision!
Oh wait....its awful. #blamesubban.
DD is consistently getting our best, and most powerful, wingers...and to boot plays against other teams weaker lines. But no!!! he plays more even strength than Eller!! I agree he does, but consider that other teams top 6 always play on the PP, the average is around 3-4 minutes per game and the average top sixer plays around 17-19 minutes per game. So thats about 13 minutes ES. Guess how much Eller and Pleks have?
Also if you recall Martin specifically said that Eller should be proud of his play, he got promoted to top 6 duties. Defensively at least.
Another thing, DD hasnt heard of the word defense. He follows the puck worse than 10 year olds. He
Patches and Cole because without him he is just a scrub.
Im sick of all this bull**** love for this guy. And if any of you, for a second, think he is better than Pleks, even offensively, then im sorry but your either oblivious or dumb.
The way desharnais set up the first goal last night says it all imho. Pass reception that was abselutely insane ... yes he worked well and made a nice pass ... but the play started with that pass reception. Watch it again ... and ask yourself this ; How is desharnais getting carried by cole and maxpac exactly ?
its called offensive flair, and this guy has plenty. He might not have the better shot/dekes/defensive play (btw, its still a lot better than what you give him credit for) ... but his offensive flair isn't far from pleks if not superior already. A lot of people said that luc robitaille had an average shot and was slow ...couldn't deke a 10 year old ... that doesn't matter. Comming from Maxpax's mouth : ''desharnais is the best player I ever played with'' .
View Public Profile
THE HOFF's albums
Find More Posts by THE HOFF