View Single Post
01-30-2012, 06:52 PM
Bring back Bonk!
Gabe84's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Montreal, QC
Country: Canada
Posts: 2,349
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by chewBACHa View Post
3) He signed Campoli.
I'm putting emphasis on this because a lot of people seem to skip over it.

Let's play a game. You are Mr. Gauthier. It is July 1st. You have these defensemen under contract:

-Markov who you think will be ready in time for the season, that's what the doctors told you (what else should you base your opinion on?).

-Gorges, solid defensive defenseman. Can play #2 minutes.

-Subban, a young, rising star in the NHL.

-Gill, whose heroics in the playoffs gave him the reputation of one of the best defensive defenseman in the league, especially on the PK.

-Spacek, reliable veteran.

Then, for the last spot, you have 3 young guys battling it out. Diaz, Emelin and Weber.

So that's 8 guys that you can have in the line-up. Signing one more defenseman makes no sense at this point.

Fast-forward to September. It's the training camp. You are happy with Diaz' camp so far. Same with Emelin and Weber, although to a lesser extent. Problem is, Markov is taking time to heal, he hasn't participated in any drills or intra games. You'd rather not play 2 of the 3 young guys every game, so what do you do?

You sign the last decent option available on the FA market: Campoli.

There. This defense can hold the fort until Markov comes back.

Sadly, the guy you JUST signed gets injured on a very iffy play during his first pre-season game. You're stuck doing exactly what you wanted to avoid: icing a very young and inexperienced defense. No more good options on the market. At least, not players you'd play over the young guys. Nobody wants to trade a decent defenseman to you early in the season, because they all want to see how their team gels. They don't want to take the risk to get a guy at the end of the pre-season because they won't have time to evaluate him.

Alright, game over. What was Gauthier supposed to do? He did the right thing. It just backfired. I think he played the whole thing well. He couldn't know Markov would take so much time when the specialists themselves told him he'd be ready.

Gabe84 is offline   Reply With Quote