Thread: Proposal: Say the Habs finish 28th...
View Single Post
02-03-2012, 02:03 PM
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 112
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by MTL-rules View Post
Jeff Carter isn't "much better" than Plekanec. He's bigger, younger and better scorer. Pleks is better defensively and has much better work ethic.

Some fans from Chicago are taking McNeil and their first +++ which is pretty good... IF this team wants to get a lotery pick next year also...

Chicago 1st = 22+ probably

Mcneill = 18th overall....

What did I say exactly ??

Originally Posted by ProMath View Post
I would Expect lower pick (16+) + young Winger/defenseman/blue chip prospect ( less valuable then Voracek was) + 3rd pick
Funny ... I said Much better ... then said what I think would be a good return... which is a bit better then what you posted....

Yes Carter is struggling this years ... but when they trading him ... he just came off a 46,33,36 goals season...

if this isnt much better then Plekanec... what is ? yes Plekanec is better defensively... but looks at the +/- of Carter during those 3 season ... + 52).

Again, don't get me wrong ... I REALLY LIKE Plekanec
Yes is work ethic is awesome. Yes he is very good defensively.
... but some Habs fan = only batman overrating their player....

Last edited by ProMath: 02-03-2012 at 02:11 PM.
ProMath is offline   Reply With Quote