Who would you rather have? Carter or Nash?
View Single Post
02-16-2012, 04:36 PM
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Tornado Alley
Originally Posted by
Actually I'll bow to our friends from Philadelphia who may remember more clearly, but I certainly don't recall Jeff Carter playing a "full" season at RW. I do recall him playing portions of seasons at wing with Richards at one time and perhaps Briere at others. The general set-up over those latter years was Briere at wing with Richards and Carter as your 1 and 2 or vice versa. When Giroux came into his own about a third of the way thru last season, Richards essentially became a 3rd line center playing lots with Carcillo and Versteeg, when he came over from Toronto. When Carter was at wing for those short periods of time during his stay in Philadelphia, my sense was he didn't look (or play) too happy. He's also not great on the boards with his body which was often complained about by fans in Philadelphia. However, I stand to be corrected if wrong on this, and still contend that Nash would be a far better fit in LA than Carter. The very last thing you want is 3 top line centers vying for prime ice time.
He played RW and LW for parts of each year of his career and is a deadly winger on the PP.
I like them both but Nash translates better to the current regime... for however long that lasts.
View Public Profile
no name's albums
Find More Posts by no name