Per Tony Marinaro: Three people he think could do the job in Montreal
View Single Post
02-23-2012, 06:56 PM
Join Date: Sep 2004
Originally Posted by
Protest the Hero
We saw what the years of being away from the game did to Barry Melrose, was he not up to date on the game from watching and commenting on it every night?
Like Andy has said, he hasn't held an actual position in the NHL in over 15 years.
LA 1992–93 84 39 35 10 - 88 3rd in Smythe Lost in Cup Final
LA 1993–94 84 27 45 12 - 66 5th in Pacific Missed Playoffs
LA 1994–95 41 13 21 7 - (33) 4th in Pacific (fired)
TB 2008–09 16 5 7 - 4 (14) 5th in Southeast (fired)
Melrose coached 3 years in the NHL, made a cup final as a rookie head coach (thank you mr.Gretzky) then missed the playoffs the next 2 seasons.
Didn't coach again until 2008, where he was fired after only 16 games. A pretty easy case could be made that he wasn't given a legitimate shot his 2nd time around... or perhaps quite simply it was painfully obvious very quickly that he wasn't prepared for the task of coaching a team.
and besides, i think a very good case could be made that coaching an NHL team is much closer to a profession requiring precise/specific technical knowledge/skill than managing one.
A good GM surrounds himself with great talent in specific areas, leans heavily on them for their expertise, and shows his "skill" in bringing the skills of all the people he surrounds himself with together to form an effective whole.
no doubt that Mcguire's biggest adjustment would be in the people management side of things, however his experience working on his broadcast teams should lend itself to smoothing the transition from being a good "teammate" to being a good leader.
Melrose jumped into a role (coaching a group of players, most of which were just starting to play hockey when he last coached) that his media job provided little cross-over for, and quite possibly even hurt him for...
likewise, if we were talking about Mcguire as a candidate for head coach, a position that he actually does have direct experience with, I'd be far less inclined to view him as a solid candidate. While his knowledge of the game, and his understanding of strategy/hockey "x's/O's" is probably just fine, running practices and managing the bench during games is the kind of specific technical skill that direct recent experience is a huge asset...
it's why a guy like Hitchcock, who took some time away doing various things, specifically spent time away from NHL coaching working as a coach at other levels, and has stepped back into the role as good/if not better, than ever.
Coaching and Managing are very different "beasts"...
View Public Profile
Miller Time's albums
Find More Posts by Miller Time