: Confirmed with Link:
[EDM/MIN] Tom Gilbert Traded For Nick Schultz - Part 2
View Single Post
03-17-2012, 10:32 AM
Join Date: Jul 2005
Originally Posted by
Let's take a step back and see what has happened here. You make an obnoxious comment about high school logic classes, and I attack your post. You respond by attacking me personally. I stoop to your level, and then you post the above, that you
me to react that way. Either you are deliberately baiting me (and others of the same disposition) or you are actually oblivious to your own noxious behaviour.
In any case, I think it will be telling to see how Schultz and Gilbert are used by their respective teams from here on. Gilbert was used in a bigger role in Edmonton than Schultz was in Minnesota.
their careers continue in that way despite switching places, I think it will be obvious who is the better defenseman.
that is true, then even if you believe Schultz is the better "fit," then Edmonton should have gotten an additional piece in return to equilibrate the difference in value.
And if the reverse is true, then what?
I would really sit down with behindthenet.ca, as you seem to hold it as the quintessential measurement of individual performance, and objectively look for the inherent flaw in using advanced stats as a measure of a single player's quality. (HINT: Hockey isn't baseball...)
View Public Profile
Ol' Jase's albums
Find More Posts by Ol' Jase