A 1994 Cup Run What-If
View Single Post
03-23-2012, 09:43 AM
Join Date: Feb 2004
Originally Posted by
I've always said to my Ranger fan friends those trades made it harder for us to win the cup that year, not easier. People assume because we won the cup, that those trades were "good". But the reality is, if we don't make those trades, we probably beat NJ and Vancouver in much less than 7 games.
The trade for Anderson was the worst. I don't care what he did against Vancouver and Bure, the fact is he almost single handedly cost us the cup the first 3 rounds with his horrific play. Meanwhile, Gartner was lighting it up in Toronto.
I wish Gartner had a chance to hold the cup that year with us, he deserved it. If you look at the intros Game 1 against Vancouver you will hear Anderson being booed. He did not have a good post season for us overall.
But alas it made for a lot of drama.
I am ambivalent about that trade (I originally hated it, but I came to recognise Anderson's contribution in the finals), but regardless, I always felt Gartner got screwed. The guy deserved a cup. I used to worry that it would keep him out of the HoF, but thankfully people realised what a great player he was.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by 007