View Single Post
04-10-2012, 12:53 PM
Join Date: Jul 2004
Originally Posted by
Girardi is more consistent, he has far fewer bad games than McD. but, imho, McD is the better defenseman. When he has a big game, you notice him. When Girardi has a big game, you dont notice him.
Well, potential to be better I think...Girardi has many years on McDonagh and has just settled down into being the consistent, steady defenseman that he is. It took him years to get to that point.
McDonagh isn't as consistent yet, he's still figuring out what he can do at the NHL level, but he's shown a higher upside in almost every area of the ice
He's not quite there to being better all around than Girardi, and I'm sure he's benefiting a great deal from playing with such a steady and solid defenseman, but he has tons of time to continue getting better. It's pretty exciting
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Levitate