View Single Post
11-22-2003, 08:26 AM
Join Date: Sep 2003
How I see the trades stack up-
(improving defense 4 trade pieces for 3 trade pieces a little more quality a little less quantity)
Stoll+Semenov+2nd > Hossa+Hainsey (were arguably improving our prospects and toning it more to our needs the difference in quality I feel is not a 2nd pick differential more like a 3rd or 4th.
(rebuild, increased size down center, and young leadership to grow with the team)
Zednik=?1st pick Atlanta(it really depends where it lands and what you think of the new Atlanta line-up I'd say 12th overall is equal to Zednik anything above is a win for Montreal and anything below is a loss)
Stefan+Stoll+2nd < Hossa+Hainsey (not gastly far off really depends if you think Stefan can ever become the player he was supposed to)
(sacrifice future for now but all the players you recieve are young so not too bad really improves offense)
Coburn=Comrie(takes another player he likes to pry him out as your GM does not want to make that swap)
Stefan < Semenov
1st pick=? Zednik
To fix this trade I would say Edmonton deceases its 2nd pick to a 3rd. Atlanta gives a 2nd pick(not quite that much maybe a 4th coming back from Mtl) or decent prospect to Montreal.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by FacelessButcher