Giroux not a finalist for the Hart Trophy?
View Single Post
04-27-2012, 07:06 PM
Join Date: Nov 2005
Originally Posted by
Shocked the above are Flyer fans. Giroux is the MVP. Period. Best player in the league this year. SO much more valuable than the players who play purely offense. PK, PP, 5 on 5, shutdown, playmaker. HE does it all. MVP. Malkin is pure offense. Stamkos couldn't get his team into the playoffs, so how valuable can you be when you take your team from playoffs last year to 10th this year? Goalies have their own trophy. Goalies have their own trophy and shouldn't be part of the discussion.
Shocked, why? Because we are capable of objectivity? And shutdown? He's great in other areas but shutting guys down isn't one of them. I'd say his defensive game has regressed this season.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by MsWoof